Chong Wai Lee, Charles and Another v. Insider Dealing Tribunal and Another

Read the full judgment text of CACV 96/2007 on BabelCite. This Court of Appeal judgment was delivered on 23 February 2010 before Rogers VP.

Corrigendum to Court of Appeal judgment dated 10 February 2010, correcting two typographical/textual errors in CACV 96/2007, CACV 102/2007, CACV 104/2007, CACV 106/2007, CACV 107/2007, CACV 108/2007, CACV 109/2007 and CACV 112/2007. The appeals arose from determinations of an Insider Dealing Tribunal in relation to Vanda Systems and Communications Holdings Limited (renamed Hutchison Global Communications Holdings Limited) pursuant to section 31 of the Securities (Insider Dealing) Ordinance, Cap. 395. The corrections concerned the representation entry on page 26 of the original judgment: the addition of 'Insider Dealing Tribunal, the 1st Respondent in person (Absent)' and the correction of counsel Mr Peter Duncan SC and Mr Jonathan Kwan, instructed by the Department of Justice, to represent the 2nd Respondent only. Corrigendum issued.

Outcome: Corrigendum issued.

Cites 2 cases

Case No.CACV 96/2007
Court
Court of Appeal
Date23 Feb 2010
JudgeRogers VP
Case Document
100%Judiciary

cacv 96/2007, CACV 102/2007, CACV 104/2007,
CACV 106/2007, CACV 107/2007, CACV 108/2007,
CACV 109/2007 and cacv 112/2007

CACV 96/2007

in the high court of the

hong kong special administrative region

court of appeal

civil appeal no. 96 of 2007

(on appeal pursuant to section 31 of the

securities (insider DEALING) ordinance, cap. 395

from determinations AND ORDERS of an

insider dealing tribunal in relation to

vanda systems and communications holdings limited)

________________________

BETWEEN

  CHONG WAI LEE, CHARLES 1st Appellant
  CHONG BUN BUN 2nd Appellant
  and  
  INSIDER DEALING TRIBUNAL 1st Respondent
  THE FINANCIAL SECRETARY 2nd Respondent
 

CACV 102/2007

in the high court of the

hong kong special administrative region

court of appeal

civil appeal no. 102 of 2007

(on appeal pursuant to section 31 of the

securities (insider DEALING) ordinance, cap. 395

from determinations AND ORDERS of an

insider dealing tribunal in relation to

vanda systems and communications holdings limited)

________________________

BETWEEN

  LI YAT TUNG DENNIS Appellant
  and  
  INSIDER DEALING TRIBUNAL 1st Respondent
  THE FINANCIAL SECRETARY 2nd Respondent
 

CACV 104/2007

in the high court of the

hong kong special administrative region

court of appeal

civil appeal no. 104 of 2007

(on appeal pursuant to section 31 of the

securities (insider DEALING) ordinance, cap. 395

from determinations AND ORDERS of an

insider dealing tribunal in relation to

vanda systems and communications holdings limited)

________________________

BETWEEN

  SILVIA CHAN YUK Appellant
  and  
  INSIDER DEALING TRIBUNAL 1st Respondent
  THE FINANCIAL SECRETARY 2nd Respondent
 

CACV 106/2007

in the high court of the

hong kong special administrative region

court of appeal

civil appeal no. 106 of 2007

(on appeal pursuant to section 31 of the

securities (insider DEALING) ordinance, cap. 395

from determinations AND ORDERS of an

insider dealing tribunal in relation to

vanda systems and communications holdings limited

(renamed as Hutchison Global Communications

Holdings Limited)(“VANDA”))

________________________

BETWEEN

  NG KIT YING DEBBIE Appellant
  and  
  INSIDER DEALING TRIBUNAL 1st Respondent
  THE FINANCIAL SECRETARY 2nd Respondent
 


CACV 107/2007

in the high court of the

hong kong special administrative region

court of appeal

civil appeal no. 107 of 2007

(on appeal pursuant to section 31 of the

securities (insider DEALING) ordinance, cap. 395

from determinations AND ORDERS of an

insider dealing tribunal in relation to

vanda systems and communications holdings limited

(renamed as Hutchison Global Communications

Holdings Limited)(“VANDA”))

________________________

BETWEEN

  CHOY MING YAN ERNEST 1st Appellant
  CHAN LAI KING BECKY 2nd Appellant
  and  
  INSIDER DEALING TRIBUNAL 1st Respondent
  THE FINANCIAL SECRETARY 2nd Respondent
 

CACV 108/2007

in the high court of the

hong kong special administrative region

court of appeal

civil appeal no. 108 of 2007

(on appeal pursuant to section 31 of the

securities (insider DEALING) ordinance, cap. 395

from determinations AND ORDERS of an

insider dealing tribunal in relation to

vanda systems and communications holdings limited

(renamed as Hutchison Global Communications

Holdings Limited)(“VANDA”))

________________________

BETWEEN

  WONG CHEUNG HUNG Appellant
  and  
  INSIDER DEALING TRIBUNAL 1st Respondent
  THE FINANCIAL SECRETARY 2nd Respondent
 

CACV 109/2007

in the high court of the

hong kong special administrative region

court of appeal

civil appeal no. 109 of 2007

(on appeal pursuant to section 31 of the

securities (insider DEALING) ordinance, cap. 395

from determinations AND ORDERS of an

insider dealing tribunal in relation to

vanda systems and communications holdings limited)

________________________

 

BETWEEN

  LAM HON NAM Appellant
  and  
  INSIDER DEALING TRIBUNAL 1st Respondent
  THE FINANCIAL SECRETARY 2nd Respondent
 

CACV 112/2007

in the high court of the

hong kong special administrative region

court of appeal

civil appeal no. 112 of 2007

(on appeal pursuant to section 31 of the

securities (insider DEALING) ordinance, cap. 395

from determinations AND ORDERS of an

insider dealing tribunal in relation to

vanda systems and communications holdings limited)

(renamed as Hutchison Global Communications

Holdings Limited)(“VANDA”))

________________________

BETWEEN

  TSE KWOK FAI SAMMY Appellant
  and  
  INSIDER DEALING TRIBUNAL

1st Respondent

  THE FINANCIAL SECRETARY 2nd Respondent

Before: Hon Rogers VP, Yeung JA and Lunn J in Court

Dates of Hearing: 19-21 January 2010

Date of Handing Down Judgment: 10 February 2010

________________________

C O R R I G E N D A

________________________

On page 26 line S, add

“Insider Dealing Tribunal, the 1st Respondent in person (Absent)”

On page 26 after line S,

“Mr Peter Duncan SC & Mr Jonathan Kwan, instructed by Department of Justice, for the 1st & 2nd Respondents”

should read

“Mr Peter Duncan SC & Mr Jonathan Kwan, instructed by Department of Justice, for the 2nd Respondent”

Dated this 23rd day of February 2010.

  (Kitty Leung)
Clerk to Hon Rogers VP