Read the full judgment text of on BabelCite..
1. Three main points were taken on the hearing of the appeal. The first was that the learned judge was not justified in finding that the exhibit relied upon by the respondent Plaintiffs as being part of the sample supplied by the Appellants was in fact part of such sample. Mr. Seidman asserted that it was and the learned judge believed him. In so believing him the learned judge must have been satisfied not only that the witness was honest but also that he was reliable. Before we could upset this