Anling Ltd and Others v. Hultucktong Enterprises Ltd and Others

Read the full judgment text of LDCS 1000/2015 on BabelCite. This LDCS judgment was delivered on 27 November 2015.

1.  On page 20, paragraph 29 (iii), between line H and I, “with copies to all other parties” should be “with copies to all other respondents”.

Cites 1 case

Case No.LDCS 1000/2015
Court
LDCS
Date27 Nov 2015
Judge
Case Document
100%Judiciary

LDCS 1000/2015

IN THE LANDS TRIBUNAL OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

APPLICATION NO. LDCS 1000 OF 2015

___________________

BETWEEN    
ANLING LIMITED (安寧有限公司) 1st Applicant
  CHERISH SHINE LIMITED (珍輝有限公司) 2nd Applicant
  FUK WANG LIMITED ( 福王有限公司) 3rd Applicant
  FULL PEARL LIMITED (珍豐有限公司) 4th Applicant
  PRIME DAY ENTERPRISES LIMITED
(朝源企業有限公司)
5th Applicant
  RAINBOW STATE HOLDINGS LIMITED
(采都控股有限公司)
6th Applicant
  XIN LEI INTERNATIONAL LIMITED 7th Applicant
  and
  HULTUCKTONG ENTERPRISES LIMITED
( 伍厚德堂企業有限公司)
1st Respondent
  HARBOURSIDE MANAGEMENT LIMITED 2nd Respondent
  PRIME WAY INVESTMENT CO. LTD.
(柏威物業投資有限公司)
3rd Respondent
  WAN YIU KEUNG (溫耀強) 4th Respondent
  YEUNG WAI SHIM (楊惠嬋) 5th Respondent
  GLORY TECH INVESTMENT LIMITED
(浩得投資有限公司)
6th Respondent
  THT CAPITAL LIMITED 7th Respondent
  WONG YUK TONG (黃沃棠) 8th Respondent
  TAM SAU KAU (譚秀球) 9th Respondent
(Discontinued)
  CHAN CHI (陳知) 10th Respondent
  CHAN BUN (陳彬) 11th Respondent
  LAI HANG KUEN (黎杏娟) 12th Respondent
  THE PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVES OF MAK WAY HO (麥維好) (DECEASED) 13th Respondent
(Discontinued)
  LEUNG LAI (梁麗) 14th Respondent
  YUEN KWING CHOI (袁烱材) ALIAS YUEN YIU MAN (袁耀文), THE ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF YUEN HING LEUNG (袁慶良) ALIAS YUEN LIN CHI (袁連枝) (DECEASED) 15th Respondent
  YUEN SAU FONG (袁秀芳) 16th Respondent
  YUNG KAM SHING (翁錦城) 17th Respondent
  CHENG YUK CHE (鄭玉枝) 18th Respondent
  CHEUNG YUEN SING (張遠勝) 19th Respondent
  TSE PAK CHUEN (謝柏泉) 20th Respondent
  TSE PAK CHUEN (謝柏泉) AND TSE PAK CHUNG (謝柏松), THE ADMINISTRATORS OF THE ESTATE OF LEUNG LAN KAM (梁蘭金) (DECEASED) 21st Respondent
  CHEUNG KIT WAI (張傑威) 22nd Respondent
  CHAU CHUNG MING CONNIE (周松明) 23rd Respondent
  MA CHING WAI WILLIAM (馬清偉), MA CHING HANG (馬清鏗) AND MA CHING YEUNG PHILIP (馬清揚), THE EXECUTORS OF THE WILL OF MA KAM CHAN (馬錦燦) (DECEASED) 24th Respondent
  KAM CHAN & COMPANY, LIMITED
(錦燦有限公司)
25th Respondent
  MA LEE SAU CHUN (馬李秀真) (IN THE WILL OF MA KAM WOON (馬錦煥), DECEASED CALLED LEE SAU CHUN (李秀真)), MA CHING KUI (馬清衢) AND MA CHING FAI BERNARD (IN THE SAID WILL CALLED MA CHING FAI) (馬清輝), THE SURVIVING EXECUTORS NAMED IN THE WILL OF MA KAM WOON (馬錦煥), DECEASED 26th Respondent
  MA CHING WA ANGELA (馬清華), THE ADMINISTRATRIX OF THE ESTATE OF CHENG SAU HING MA (馬鄭秀卿) ALSO KNOWN AS MA CHENG SAU HING (馬鄭秀卿) (DECEASED) 27th Respondent
  CHONG HING BANK LIMITED
(創興銀行有限公司)
28th Respondent
  DBS BANK (HONG KONG) LIMITED
(星展銀行(香港)有限公司)
29th Respondent
  STANDARD CHARTERED BANK (HONG KONG) LIMITED
(渣打銀行(香港)有限公司)
30th Respondent
  CHINA CONSTRUCTION BANK (ASIA) CORPORATION LIMITED
(中國建設銀行(亞洲)股份有限公司)
31st Respondent
  MA CHING LEONG DANIEL (馬清亮), MA CHING TSUN, ALEXANDER (馬清俊)ALSO KNOWN AS MA CHING TSUN (馬清俊), MA CHING CHUNG, ROBERT (馬清松) ALSO KNOWN AS MA CHING CHUNG (馬清松) AND MA CHING HUNG (馬清鴻),THE EXECUTORS OF THE WILL OF MA KAM CHIU (馬錦釗), DECEASED 32nd Respondent
  THE PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVES OF MA KAM MING (馬錦明) (DECEASED) 33rd Respondent
  CHEUNG TAK KUEN 34th Respondent

___________________

Before: His Honour Judge K W WONG, Presiding Officer of the Lands Tribunal, in Court
Date of Hearing: 17November 2015
Date of Decision: 27 November 2015
Date of Corrigendum: 22 December 2015

___________________

CORRIGENDUM

___________________

1.  On page 20, paragraph 29 (iii), between line H and I, “with copies to all other parties” should be “with copies to all other respondents”.

(Carmen Leung)
Clerk to H H Judge K W WONG