|
FAMV Nos 6 & 7 of 2019
[2019] HKCFA 21
FAMV No 6 of 2019
IN THE COURT OF FINAL APPEAL OF THE
HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION
MISCELLANEOUS PROCEEDINGS NO 6 OF 2019 (CIVIL)
(ON APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL FROM
CACV NO 158 OF 2012)
________________________
BETWEEN
|
廈門新景地集團有限公司
formerly known as
廈門市鑫新景地房地產有限公司 |
Plaintiff
(Applicant)
|
|
and |
|
|
ETON PROPERTIES LIMITED
(裕景興業有限公司) |
1st Defendant
(1st Respondent)
|
|
ETON PROPERTIES (HOLDINGS) LIMITED
(裕景興業(集團)有限公司) |
2nd Defendant
(2nd Respondent)
|
|
ETON PROPERTIES GROUP LIMITED formerly known as ETON PROPERTIES (INTERNATIONAL) LIMITED |
3rd Defendant
(3rd Respondent)
|
|
LEGEND PROPERTIES (XIAMEN)
COMPANY LIMITED (利景興業（廈門）有限公司), a limited company incorporated in Hong Kong |
4th Defendant
(4th Respondent)
|
|
LEGEND PROPERTIES (XIAMEN) COMPANY LIMITED (利景興業（廈門）有限公司), a foreign-owned enterprise incorporated in the People’s Republic of China |
5th Defendant
|
|
TAN LUCIO C（陳永栽） |
6th Defendant
(5th Respondent)
|
|
CHUA DOMINGO（蔡黎明） |
7th Defendant
|
|
TAN ENG LIEN MARIANO（陳永年） |
8th Defendant
|
|
KWAN KIE YIP（關基業） |
9th Defendant
|
|
CHEUNG CHI MING（張志明） |
10th Defendant
|
|
MOK PUI HONG（莫沛杭） |
11th Defendant
|
________________________
FAMV No 7 of 2019
IN THE COURT OF FINAL APPEAL OF THE
HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION
MISCELLANEOUS PROCEEDINGS NO 7 OF 2019 (CIVIL)
(ON APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL FROM
CACV NO 158 OF 2012)
BETWEEN
|
廈門新景地集團有限公司
formerly known as
廈門市鑫新景地房地產有限公司 |
Plaintif
(Respondent)
|
|
and |
|
|
ETON PROPERTIES LIMITED
(裕景興業有限公司) |
1st Defendant
(1st Applicant)
|
|
ETON PROPERTIES (HOLDINGS) LIMITED
(裕景興業(集團)有限公司) |
2nd Defendant
(2nd Applicant)
|
|
ETON PROPERTIES GROUP LIMITED formerly known as ETON PROPERTIES (INTERNATIONAL) LIMITED |
3rd Defendant
|
|
LEGEND PROPERTIES (XIAMEN)
COMPANY LIMITED (利景興業（廈門）有限公司), a limited company incorporated in Hong Kong |
4th Defendant
|
|
LEGEND PROPERTIES (XIAMEN) COMPANY LIMITED (利景興業（廈門）有限公司), a foreign-owned enterprise incorporated in the People’s Republic of China |
5th Defendant
|
|
TAN LUCIO C（陳永栽） |
6th Defendant
|
|
CHUA DOMINGO（蔡黎明） |
7th Defendant
|
|
TAN ENG LIEN MARIANO（陳永年） |
8th Defendant
|
|
KWAN KIE YIP（關基業） |
9th Defendant
|
|
CHEUNG CHI MING（張志明） |
10th Defendant
|
|
MOK PUI HONG（莫沛杭） |
11th Defendant
|
________________________
| Appeal Committee:
Mr Justice Cheung PJ, Mr Justice Bokhary NPJ and
Mr Justice Chan NPJ
|
| Date of Hearing and Determination:
3 June 2019
|
| Date of Corrigendum:
5 June 2019
|
________________________
CORRIGENDUM
________________________
Please note the following amendment in the Determination dated 3 June 2019:
At paragraph 7 on page 5:
“… which turns on the scope of the arbitration argument in question.” should read “…which turns on the scope of the arbitration agreement in question.”
Dated this 5th day of June 2019.
| |
(Charlotte Chan) |
| |
for Acting Registrar, CFA |
|