Case Document

100%Judiciary

CACV 541/2019

[2019] HKCA 1396

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF APPEAL

CIVIL APPEAL NO 541 OF 2019

(ON APPEAL FROM HCAL 2949/2019)

________________

BETWEEN
	LEUNG KWOK HUNG （梁國雄）	Applicant
	and
	SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE	1^st Respondent
	CHIEF EXECUTIVE IN COUNCIL	2^nd Respondent

________________

CACV 542/2019

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF APPEAL

CIVIL APPEAL NO 542 OF 2019

(ON APPEAL FROM HCAL 2945/2019)

________________

BETWEEN
	KWOK WING HANG	1st Applicant
	CHEUNG CHIU HUNG	2nd Applicant
	TO KUN SUN JAMES	3rd Applicant
	LEUNG YIU CHUNG	4th Applicant
	JOSEPH LEE KOK LONG	5th Applicant
	MO, MAN CHING CLAUDIA	6th Applicant
	WU CHI WAI	7th Applicant
	CHAN CHI-CHUEN RAYMOND	8th Applicant
	LEUNG KAI CHEONG KENNETH	9th Applicant
	KWOK KA-KI	10th Applicant
	WONG PIK WAN	11th Applicant
	IP KIN-YUEN	12th Applicant
	YEUNG ALVIN NGOK KIU	13th Applicant
	ANDREW WAN SIU KIN	14th Applicant
	CHU HOI DICK EDDIE	15th Applicant
	LAM CHEUK-TING	16th Applicant
	SHIU KA CHUN	17th Applicant
	TANYA CHAN	18th Applicant
	HUI CHI FUNG	19th Applicant
	KWONG CHUN-YU	20th Applicant
	TAM MAN HO JEREMY JANSEN	21st Applicant
	FAN, GARY KWOK WAI	22nd Applicant
	AU NOK HIN	23rd Applicant
	CHARLES PETER MOK	24th Applicant
and
	CHIEF EXECUTIVE IN COUNCIL	1st Respondent
	SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE	2nd Respondent

________________

Before:

Hon Poon Ag CJHC and Hon Lam VP

Dates of Written Submissions:	29 November, 2 and 4 December 2019
Date of Judgment:	10 December 2019
Date of Corrigendum:	13 December 2019

_________________

CORRIGENDUM

_________________

1.In paragraph 17 at page 8, the first sentence should read “The respondents have not really tackled Sir Anthony Mason NPJ’s reservation and the doctrinal and logical difficulties in their written submissions.”