Convoy Collateral Ltd v. Cho Kwai Chee (also known as Cho Kwai Chee Roy) and Others

Case No.CACV 197/2020[2020] HKCA 537
Court
Court of Appeal
Date16 Jun 2020
JudgeLam VP and Barma JA
Case Document
100%

CACV 197/2020
and CAMP 38/2020
(Heard together)

[2020] HKCA 537

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF APPEAL

CIVIL APPEAL NO 197 OF 2020

(ON APPEAL FROM HCA 399/2018)

AND

MISCELLANEOUS PROCEEDING NO 38 OF 2020

(ON AN INTENDED APPEAL FROM HCA 399/2018)

________________________

BETWEEN    
CONVOY COLLATERAL LIMITED Plaintiff
and
CHO KWAI CHEE (also known as CHO KWAI CHEE ROY) 1st Defendant
TAN YE KAI BYRON 2nd Defendant
CHAN LAI YEE CHRISTIE 3rd Defendant
NG YAO KWOK 4th Defendant
NG MEN KIT
(also known as NG MEN KIT BILLY)
5th Defendant
HON SIU HONG 6th Defendant
CHAN WANG FAI ANDY 7th Defendant
CHEUNG WAN HUNG GILBERT 8th Defendant
LAM CHI YUNG PAUL 9th Defendant
CHECKMATE FINANCE HONG KONG LIMITED 10th Defendant
CHINA GREEN (HOLDINGS) LIMITED 11th Defendant
ATHENA POWER LIMITED 12th Defendant
ZHANG XIONGFENG 13th Defendant

_________________________________

(Heard together)

Before: Hon Lam VP and Barma JA in Court

Date of Hearing: 16 June 2020

Date of Judgment: 16 June 2020

Date of Reasons for Judgment: 3 July 2020

Date of Corrigendum: 8 July 2020

Date of 2nd Corrigendum: 7 September 2020

_________________________

2nd CORRIGENDUM

_________________________

Please note the following corrigendum for the Reasons for Judgment dated the 3rd July 2020: -

1.     Page 29, line Q, “Mr Steward Wong SC” should read “Mr Stewart Wong SC”.

Dated the 7th day of September 2020

(Stanley Hui)
for Registrar, High Court

Related Cases
Ranked by citation overlap · cases that cite each other appear first

Beijing Renji Real Estate Development Group Co., Ltd v. Zhu Min

HCMP 83/2020 · High Court CFI
07 Apr 2022
cites this
Full analysis

Nicholas v. A. Schebek Fuerstenberg v. Yip Wai Sang and Another

HCA 221/2017 · High Court CFI
23 Jul 2020
cites this

Kwok Hiu Kwan v. Convoy Global Holdings Ltd

HCMP 1578/2020 · High Court CFI
13 Nov 2020
cites this

Flexi Credits Ltd v. Wong Chi Kit Clement

HCA 738/2022 · High Court CFI
18 Jul 2022
cites this
Cited by 44 cases

Other judgments that cite this case

Guangzhou Hengtai Biotechnology (Hong Kong) Ltd v. Chan Kim Chung, Nelson and Another
High Court CFI
16 Jun 2026
華融華僑資產管理股份有限公司 v. 李晓鹏
Court of First Instance
22 Dec 2025
Full analysis
Axht Company Ltd v. 王一诚
High Court CFI
10 Dec 2025
Axht Company Ltd v. 王一诚
High Court CFI
30 Sep 2025