Orient Sea Investments Ltd and Others v. Cheung Wing Ching and Others

Read the full judgment text of LDCS 27000/2018 on BabelCite. This LDCS judgment was delivered on 24 August 2020.

1. Please note the following corrigenda in the Judgment dated 24 August 2020: -

Cites 1 case

Case No.LDCS 27000/2018
Court
LDCS
Date24 Aug 2020
Judge
Case Document
100%Judiciary

LDCS 27000/2018

[2020] HKLdT 30

IN THE LANDS TRIBUNAL OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

LAND COMPULSORY SALE MAIN APPLICATION NO. 27000 OF 2018

__________________________

BETWEEN

  ORIENT SEA INVESTMENTS LIMITED 1st Applicant
  TOP SCORE PROPERTIES LIMITED
(德成置業有限公司)
2nd Applicant
  MILLION TOP PROPERTIES LIMITED
(萬得置業有限公司)
3rd Applicant
  RADIANT OCEAN PROPERTIES LIMITED 4th Applicant
  GOLD DYNASTY ENTERPRISES LIMITED
(金德企業有限公司)
5th Applicant
  VICTORY SUCCEED LIMITED
(威達勝有限公司)
6th Applicant
  SOLAR KING LIMITED
(立強有限公司)
7th Applicant
  STAR LINK ENTERPRISES LIMITED
(信領企業有限公司)
8th Applicant
  VICTORY HARVEST CORPORATION LIMITED
(慶灃有限公司)
9th Applicant
  RICH METROPO LIMITED
(都達有限公司)
10th Applicant
  CHINA WINNER INVESTMENTS LIMITED
(華凱投資有限公司)
11th Applicant
  GLORY ALLIANCE INVESTMENTS LIMITED
(輝聯投資有限公司)
12th Applicant
  WAYSON HONG KONG INVESTMENT LIMITED (滙信香港有限公司) 13th Applicant
  and
  CHEUNG WING CHING (張永正) 1st Respondent (discontinued)
  TAI BUT TUNG SHOE COMPANY LIMITED
(大不同皮鞋有限公司)
2nd Respondent (discontinued)
  KINGMODE INVESTMENT LIMITED
(京貿投資有限公司)
3rd Respondent
(discontinued)
  LOK SING TOM, The Intended Personal Representative of the Estate of HONG TEN TOM also known as TOM HONG TEN also known as HUM HAI KEUNG (譚希強) (deceased) 4th Respondent
  ETERNAL RISE INDUSTRIAL COMPANY LIMITED (源溢實業有限公司) 5th Respondent (discontinued)
  HONG KONG ENTERPRISES LIMITED 6th Respondent (discontinued)
  YEUNG LAI HO THOMAS (楊禮豪) 7th Respondent (discontinued)
  KEY FIELD ESTATE LIMITED
(盛塘發展有限公司)
8th Respondent (discontinued)
  SI SAU WAH (施秀華) 9th Respondent (discontinued)
  LEE MIN MIN (李綿綿) 10th Respondent (discontinued)
  YING MAI LING (殷美玲), the Administratrix of the Estate of YING CHING DOR also known as YAN TSUN TO (殷進道) (deceased) 11th Respondent (discontinued)
  CHONG CHE CHUNG (莊志聰) 12th Respondent (discontinued)
  LEE MICHELLE (李蜜茜) 13th Respondent (discontinued)
  SO WU HUK (蘇烏核) 14th Respondent (discontinued)
  LI CHEN PENG (李振鵬), the Administrator of the Estate of LAM YICK SAN (or SHAN) (林奕珊) (deceased) 15th Respondent
  The Personal Representatives of EDWARD CHAN (alias: CHAN TAK TAI) (陳德泰)(deceased) 16th Respondent
  WONG YUK LAN (黃玉蘭) 17th Respondent (discontinued)
  NG HUNG KWAN (吳洪焜) 18th Respondent (discontinued)
  NGO SAM (陳明從) 19th Respondent
  HO CHAU HEUNG (何秋香) 20th Respondent
  LAI LEE HING (黎麗卿) 21st Respondent
  LAI YIN HING (黎燕卿) 22nd Respondent
  LI WOON HUN (李垣亨) 23rd Respondent (discontinued)
  LI FOOK WING (李福榮) 24th Respondent (discontinued)
  WANG JEN KANG (王人康) 25th Respondent
  HUI LAI NAI (許麗娜) 26th Respondent
  SIU SIN CHUNG (邵善聰) 27th Respondent (discontinued)
  SHIU KING YEUNG (邵景陽) 28th Respondent (discontinued)
  WONG KAM SANG (黃金生)(formerly known as WONG ERNEST JOHN (黃金生), the Executor of the Will of WONG SHEK WAH (黃石華)(deceased) 29th Respondent (discontinued)
  SIA GAN HOY 30th Respondent
  SIA NUY 31st Respondent
  CATHERINE YEE 32nd Respondent
  KWONG WING LAN (鄺泳蘭) 33rd Respondent (discontinued)
  HUNG LAI WAN(洪麗雲) 34th Respondent (discontinued)
  WONG LEUNG WING, a mentally incapacitated person, by TSOI PUI WAH his wife and Guardian Ad Litem 35th Respondent

__________________________

Before: Mr Lawrence Pang, Member of the Lands Tribunal
Dates of Hearing: 2 July 2020
Date of Judgment: 24 August 2020
Date of Corrigenda: 25 September 2020

______________________

C O R R I G E N D U M

______________________

1. Please note the following corrigenda in the Judgment dated 24 August 2020: -

2. In paragraph 22, the respondent(s) for Unit Flat 9L be changed from “R21”to “R21” & “R22”;

3. In paragraph 69(2), “22nd” be added in between “21st” and “25th”;

4. In paragraph 69(5)(v), “22nd” be added in between “21st “and “25th”;

5. In paragraph 70(i), “22nd” be added in between “21st” and “25th”;

6. The Respondents who were absent and unrepresented during the hearing on 2 July 2020, “22nd” be added in between “21st” and “26th”.

Dated this 25th day of September 2020.

  (Ms Iris YEUNG)
  Clerk to Member Lawrence Pang