Amjad-ul-mahmood v. Profit Hill International Holdings Ltd and Another

Read the full judgment text of DCPI 534/2017 on BabelCite. This District Court judgment was delivered on 21 March 2023.

1. Page 2, paragraph 4 “… The proceedings was settled as D1 paid a sum of HK$338,000 (inclusive of costs) to P.” should read as “… The proceedings was settled as D1 paid a sum of HK$338,000 (exclusive of costs) to P”.

Cited by 2 cases · Cites 1 case

Case No.DCPI 534/2017[2023] HKDC 347
Court
District Court
Date21 Mar 2023
Judge
Case Document
100%Judiciary

DCPI 534/2017

[2023] HKDC 347

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

PERSONAL INJURIES ACTION NO 534 OF 2017

---------------------------

BETWEEN

  AMJAD-UL-MAHMOOD Plaintiff
  and  
  PROFIT HILL INTERNATIONAL HOLDINGS LIMITED 1st Defendant
  THE INCORPORATED OWNERS OF DAILY HOUSE 2nd Defendant

---------------------------

Before: Deputy District Judge Rebecca Lee in Court
Date of Hearing: 26 - 29 September 2022 & 20 December 2022
Date of Judgment: 21 March 2023
Date of Corrigendum: 7 June 2023

--------------------------

CORRIGENDUM

--------------------------

Please note the following amendments in the Judgment handed down on 21 March 2023:-

1.Page 2, paragraph 4 “… The proceedings was settled as D1 paid a sum of HK$338,000 (inclusive of costs) to P.” should read as “… The proceedings was settled as D1 paid a sum of HK$338,000 (exclusive of costs) to P”.

2.Page 29, paragraph 120 “The sums claimed by D1 (which are not disputed by D2) are as follows:

  EC Amount paid to P $338,000
  P’s own costs $40,000
  D1’s costs $21,760.40
  Interest $106,602.66
  Total: $506,363 (round up)”

should read as The sums recoverable by D1 from D2 are as follows:

EC Amount paid to P

(up to the amount of damages awarded to P

  In the sum of $247,515 together with interest) $291,910.20
  P’s own costs   $40,000
  D1’s costs   $21,760.40
  Interest   $90,775.5
  Total:   $444,446 (round up)”

3.Page 29, paragraph 121 “I order that D2 do pay D1 the sum of $506,363 under the Contribution and Indemnity Proceedings.” should read as I order that D2 do pay D1 the sum of $444,446 under the Contribution and Indemnity Proceedings.”.

Dated the 7th day of June 2023

  ( M.H. MA (Miss))
Clerk to Deputy District Judge Rebecca Lee