Peace Ever Ltd and Others v. Chan Sui Ching, The Person Appointed To Represent the Estate of Leung Lap (梁立), Deceased (By Carry on Order Dated 17th December 2020) and Others

Case No.LDCS 28000/2018

Court

LDCS

Date01 Aug 2023

Judge—

Case Document

100%Judiciary

LDCS 28000/2018

[2023] HKLdT 41

IN THE LANDS TRIBUNAL OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

LAND COMPULSORY SALE MAIN APPLICATION NO. 28000 OF 2018

________________________

BETWEEN

	PEACE EVER LIMITED (安建有限公司)	1^st Applicant
	CITY HEALTH LIMITED (忠康有限公司)	2^nd Applicant
	YES KING (HK) LIMITED (友皇 (香港)有限公司)	3^rd Applicant
	POLLOCK DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED	4^th Applicant
	WEALTH FIRST LIMITED (豐致有限公司)	5^th Applicant
	MARVEL CASTLE LIMITED (妙堡有限公司)	6^th Applicant
	CROWN WAY CAPITAL LIMITED (冠威資本有限公司)	7^th Applicant
	MILLION MAPLE LIMITED (順昌有限公司)	8^th Applicant
	NEW CENTURY DEVICE CO., LTD	9^th Applicant
	SNAP INTERNATIONAL LIMITED (市立國際有限公司)	10^th Applicant
	TRIMBA INTERNATIONAL LIMITED	11^th Applicant
	CHARMPOINT LIMITED	12^th Applicant
	QUICK SUCCESSION LIMITED	13^th Applicant
	CHINA LOGISTIC INNOVATION CO., LTD	14^th Applicant
	GURU STAR INTERNATIONAL LIMITED (星優國際有限公司)	15^th Applicant
	BOARDLANE BUSINESS ENTERPRISES CO., LTD	16^th Applicant
	KUAMIN HOLDINGS LIMITED	17^th Applicant
	and
	AU KAI (歐啟)	1^st Respondent (Discontinued)
	CHAN SUI CHING (陳瑞貞), the Person Appointed to Represent the Estate of LEUNG LAP (梁立), deceased (by Carry On Order dated 17^th December 2020)	2^nd Respondent
	LEE SHUK LI (李淑莉)	3^rd Respondent
	WONG SAU MING as Administratrix of the Estate of SO SHAM MUI (蘇三妹), deceased	4^th Respondent (Discontinued)
	LAI WING KEE (黎永棋) and LAI HOI WING WINNIE (黎凱詠)	5^th Respondents
	WONG KWAN SUN (王鋆燊)	6^th Respondent (Discontinued)
	CHAN SIU (陳紹)	7^th Respondent
	LAM WING SHING (林永成) and LAM LEE LEE LILY (林莉莉) as Executors of the Estate of HUI BIU HA (許標霞), deceased	8^th Respondents
	LEE CHI CHEONG FRANCIS (李志昌) alias LEE CHI CHEONG (李志昌)	9^th Respondent (Discontinued)
	HUI KIM KWONG (許劍光) as Administrator of the Estate of SIU KAU KWOK HUI alias KWOK SIK KAU (郭色球), deceased	10^th Respondent (Discontinued)
	KWOK HING WA (郭興華) and KWOK FU WAH (郭富華)	11^th Respondents
	KANGOL COMPANY LIMITED (敬都有限公司)	12^th Respondent (Discontinued)
	LEE SEEN PING (李倩萍)	13^th Respondent
	WINTEK ENGINEERING COMPANY LIMITED (宏得工程有限公司)	14^th Respondent (Discontinued)
	CHAN HONG WING (陳康永)	15^th Respondent
	TOU FONG LAN (杜鳳蘭)	16^th Respondent
	EVANGELIZE CHINA FELLOWSHIP MAAN SHIN CHURCH LIMITED (基督教中國佈道會萬善堂有限公司)	17^th Respondent
	HO CHING NGOK (何靖獄) as Administrator of the Estate of CHAN MAY TSING (陳梅清), deceased	18^th Respondent (Discontinued)
	WONG SAU MING (王秀明) and WONG KWAN SUN (王鋆燊) as Executors of the Estate of WONG TONG (王棠), deceased	19^th Respondents (Discontinued)
	WISE VOICE INVESTMENTS LIMITED (宏旺投資有限公司)	20^th Respondent (Discontinued)
	WONG MUK HA (黃木霞) (also known as YEUNG WONG MUK HA (楊黃木霞))	21^st Respondent
	LI KA HING (李嘉興) and CHENG SUK NGAN, GRACE (鄭淑顏)	22^nd Respondents
	WONG CHI (黃芝) and HUANG DONGYU (黃東育)	23^rd Respondents (Discontinued)
	LEE SAM KIN (李三根)	24^th Respondent
	LEE YUM WONG (李欽煌) and LAI JOE MEI (黎佐妹)	25^th Respondents (Discontinued)
	Personal Representative of LIU PO KIU (廖宝喬) (or otherwise known as LIU POH KIOH), deceased	1^st Named 26^th Respondent
	LIU KAI CHU REBECCA (廖繼珠) as Administratrix of the Estate of LIU KEE YEE (廖紀儀), deceased	2^nd Named 26^th Respondent (Discontinued)
	CHAN TING KWOK TERRENCE (陳定國) alias TERRENCE CHAN (in the Will called CHAN TING KWOK (陳定國) alias TERRENCE CHAN) as Executor of the Estate of CHAN MUN (陳敏) alias CHAN MAN (陳敏) alias CHAN WAI (陳慧) alias CHAN WAI CHING (陳慧貞), deceased	27^th Respondent
	R. CORNEY AND COMPANY, LIMITED (明新有限公司)	28^th Respondent (Discontinued)
	LU PO HON (陸保漢) as Administrator of the Estate of LU CHIU SUM (陸釗琛), deceased	29^th Respondent
	CHU MAN YEE JENNY (朱曼頣)	30^th Respondent (Discontinued)
	YAU YU (邱愉) and SUEN LAI PING (孫麗萍)	31^st Respondents (Discontinued)
	SIT WAI MING (薜偉明)	32^nd Respondent (Discontinued)
	SIT LAI HING SOPHIA (薜麗卿)	33^rd Respondent (Discontinued)
	EQUAL GLOBAL LIMITED	34^th Respondent (Discontinued)
	The Personal Representative of HENRY AYEE, deceased (死者謝就宇的遺產代理人) and TUM SAU HAIR (譚秀霞)	35^th Respondent
	LEE YUK LUN (李旭麟)	36^th Respondent
	LEUNG YUEN YEE FRANCES (梁婉儀) and LEUNG KWOK HUNG (梁國雄)	37^th Respondents (Discontinued)
	NG KUK YING (吳菊英)	38^th Respondent
	POPWAY INVESTMENT LIMITED	39^th Respondent
	DUCTILE INVESTMENT COMPANY LIMITED (德泰置業有限公司)	40^th Respondent (Discontinued)
	HUN TAI SUN (洪大山) and WU BO LING (胡保齡)	41^st Respondents
	WATT KEI (屈圻)	42^nd Respondent
	CHENG PO FAN (鄭寶芬)	43^rd Respondent (Discontinued)

________________________

Before:

Deputy District Judge S H Lee, Presiding Officer of the Lands Tribunal and Mr Lawrence PANG, Member of the Lands Tribunal

Dates of Hearing:	12-16, 19-20 December 2022
Date of Joint Site Inspection:	13 December 2022
Date of Parties’ Closing Submissions:	17 January 2023
Date of Respondents’ Reply Submissions (if any):	7 February 2023 23 March 2023 (R7 only)
Date of Applicants’ Reply Submissions:	7 March 2023
Date of Handing Down of Judgment:	1 August 2023
Date of Corrigenda:	11 August 2023

________________________

C O R R I G E N D U M

________________________

1.Please note the following corrigenda in the Judgment dated 1 August 2023:-

2.The name of the 17^th Respondent in the title should be “EVANGELIZE CHINA FELLOWSHIP MAAN SHIN CHURCH LIMITED (基督教中國佈道會萬善堂有限公司)”.

3.In line 1 of paragraph 315, the figure “2,654,833,000” should be read as “2,670,922,000”. In the table under paragraph 315, the EUV figure of Upper Floor Units in Building at Nos 88-94 Pan Hoi Street “$146,101,000” should read as “$146,317,000”.

Dated this 11^th day of August 2023

	(Ms YEUNG Fung Yan)
	Clerk to Member Lawrence Pang

Cites 1 case

Cases cited in this judgment

Peace Ever Ltd and Others v. Chan Sui Ching, The Person Appointed To Represent the Estate of Leung Lap (梁立), Deceased (By Carry on Order Dated 17th December 2020) and Others

LDCS 28000/2018

LDCS01 Aug 2023

Other Judgments in This Case

Further hearings and rulings under LDCS 28000/2018

Peace Ever Ltd and Others v. Chan Sui Ching, The Person Appointed To Represent the Estate of Leung Lap (梁立), Deceased (By Carry on Order Dated 17th December 2020) and Others

LDCS01 Aug 2023