Read the full judgment text of FCMC 4633/2020 on BabelCite. This Family Court judgment was delivered on 21 September 2023 before His Honour Judge G. Own.
Matrimonial Causes – Rule 121 Matrimonial Causes Rules – Leave to Appeal – District Court Ordinance s.63A – Disclosure of Documents – Domestic Helper – Criminal Proceedings – Judicial Proceedings (Regulations of Reports) Ordinance s.5(1) – Whether Petitioner is proper party for Rule 121 application – Whether Two-Stage Approach applicable – Whether witness can provide documents – Whether court took into account irrelevant considerations – Whether court failed to take into account material considerations – Whether JPRRO breached – Leave to appeal dismissed – Costs awarded to Respondent.
Legal issues: Ground 1: Proper Party for the Rule 121 Application · Ground 2: Two-Stage Approach to Disclosure · Ground 3: Witness Providing Additional Information · Ground 4: Irrelevant Considerations · Ground 5: Material Considerations (Conviction Risk) · Ground 6: Breaches of JPRRO
Outcome: Application for leave to appeal dismissed.
Cited by 1 case · Cites 1 case