Tam Li Kam Wah Agnes v. Wong Pui Hang William and Another

Read the full judgment text of HCPI 117/2017 on BabelCite. This High Court CFI judgment was delivered on 11 December 2024.

1. At page 4, paragraph 8, lines B and C, “7/1/2021 Judgment” should read “14/1/2022 Judgment”

Cited by 1 case · Cites 1 case

Case No.HCPI 117/2017[2024] HKCFI 3580
Court
High Court CFI
Date11 Dec 2024
Judge
Case Document
100%Judiciary

HCPI 117/2017

[2024] HKCFI 3580

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

PERSONAL INJURIES ACTION NO 117 OF 2017

________________________

BETWEEN    
  TAM LI KAM WAH AGNES,
THE ADMINISTRATRIX OF THE ESTATE OF
TAM MICHAEL ARTHUR SHIU CHEUNG,
THE DECEASED, AND IN HER PERSONAL CAPACITY
Plaintiff

and

  WONG PUI HANG WILLIAM (黃佩恆),
the Administrator of the estate of
WONG IAN YIK, deceased
1st Defendant
  LIBERTY INTERNATIONAL INSURANCE LIMITED 2nd Defendant

________________________

Before: Hon Leung J in Court
Dates of Hearing: 27- 28 November 2023 and 6 February 2024
Date of Judgment on Assessment of Damages: 11 December 2024
Date of Corrigendum: 16 December 2024

____________________

CORRIGENDUM

____________________

Please note the following amendments to the Judgment on Assessment of Damages dated 11 December 2024:-

1.At page 4, paragraph 8, lines B and C, “7/1/2021 Judgment” should read “14/1/2022 Judgment”

2.At page 38, paragraph 117, between lines M and N, “18.89 years” should read “19.89 years”

3.At page 38, paragraph 117, between lines N and O, “… would be between of 14.53 and 15.17, and hence 15.1” should read “… would be between 15.78 and 15.17, and hence 15.71”

4.At page 38, paragraph 118, line T, “… the Mother’s future loss of dependency will be HK$3,763 x 115.8% x 12 x 15.1 = say HK$789,589” should read “… the Mother’s future loss of dependency will be HK$3,763 x 115.8% x 12 x 15.71 = say HK$821,486”

5.At page 61, paragraph 1813, between lines E and F at the last row of the table, “JFO” should be removed from “Mid-2023 – present JFO”.

6.At page 66, paragraph 205, line S, “HK$218,908” should read “HK$139,103”

7.At page 68, paragraph 207, line E, “Total interest: HK$(218,908 + 365,658) = HK$584,566.” should read “Total interest: HK$(139,103 + 365,658) = HK$504,761.”

8.At page 68, paragraph 208, line K, “The Mother  HK$789,589” should read “The Mother  HK$821,486”

9.At page 68, paragraph 208, between lines N and O, “INTEREST  HK$584,566” should read “INTEREST  HK$504,761”

10.At page 68, paragraph 208, between lines O and P, “TOTAL: HK$10,733,770” should read “TOTAL: HK$10,685,862”

11.At page 68, paragraph 209, line R, “… the amount becomes HK$10,733,770 x 85% = say HK$9,123,705.” should read “… the amount becomes HK$10,685,862 x 85% = say HK$$9,082,983.”

12.At page 69, paragraph 210, line C, “HK$9,123,705” should read “HK$9,082,983”

  (Minnie Ko)
  for Registrar, High Court