Pacific Bulk Shipping Ltd and Another v. Topmove Ltd and Another

HCA 1431/2015

[2025] HKCFI 532

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

ACTION NO. 1431 OF 2015

____________________

BETWEEN

____________________

HCA 228/2017

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

ACTION NO. 228 OF 2017

____________________

BETWEEN

____________________

(Heard Together)

________________

CORRIGENDA

________________

Please note the following corrections in the Judgment handed down on 13 February 2025:-

(1) Page 9, paragraph 25, 2^nd line, “BP Bahamas” should read “PB Bahamas”;

(2) Page 12, paragraph 33, 2^nd line, “Intemational” should read “International”;

(3) Page 21, paragraph 74, 1^st line, “declarution” should read “declaration”;

(4) Page 25, paragraph 87, 3^rd line, “Lau (He)” should read “Lau (Ms Sun Min)”;

(5) Page 29, paragraph 94, 2^nd line, “evidence of the witnesses. I prefer…” should read “evidence of the witnesses, I prefer…”;

(6) Page 29, paragraph 95, 1^st line, “Mr Joffee” should read “Mr Joffe”;

(7) Page 35, paragraph 111, 4^th line, “He did no keep” should read “He did not keep”;

(8) Page 36, paragraph 115, 3^rd line, “35%, 35%” should read “37.5%, 37.5%”;

(9) Page 37, footnote 19, “A1/3/52, [2(f)]” should read “A1/3/52, [2(e)]”;

(10) Page 44, paragraph 129(1), 2^nd line, “intter alia” should read “inter alia”;

(11) Page 48, quotation 1.6, 2^nd line, “原周” should read “原則”;

(12) Page 48, quotation 2.5, 1^st line, “系研” should read “系列”;

(13) Page 56, paragraph 151, the line before quotation, “stated as follow” should read “stated as follows”;

(14) Page 59, paragraph 161(1), 4^th line, “(b) on 26 October 2008” should read “(b) on 28 October 2008”;

(15) Page 59, footnote 58, “B1/23/481, [74]” should read “B1/29/481, [74]”;

(16) Page 60, paragraph 163, 3^rd line, “Mr Joffee” should read “Mr Joffe”;

(17) Page 64, paragraph 176, 5^th line, “hammar out” should read “hammer out”;

(18) Page 64, the representatives of Sit Fung Kwong & Shum, “Mr Victor Joffe SC, Mr Mike Lui SC and Mr Keith Chan, instructed by…” should read “Mr William Wong SC and Mr Charlie Liu, instructed by…”; and

(19) Page 64, the representatives of Lau, Horton & Wise LLP, “Mr William Wong SC and Mr Charlie Liu, instructed by…” should read “Mr Victor Joffe SC, Mr Mike Lui SC and Mr Keith Chan, instructed by…”.

Dated this 20^th day of February 2025