Wise Grace Investment Ltd and Others v. Lui Man Dung and Others

Read the full judgment text of LDCS 15000/2021 on BabelCite. This LDCS judgment was delivered on 13 February 2025.

1. On page 61, in the 8 th line from the top, the party “R5” should be corrected as “R3”.

Cites 1 case

Case No.LDCS 15000/2021
Court
LDCS
Date13 Feb 2025
Judge
Case Document
100%Judiciary

LDCS 15000/2021

[2025] HKLdT 5

IN THE LANDS TRIBUNAL OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

LAND COMPULSORY SALE MAIN APPLICATION NO 15000 OF 2021

__________________________

BETWEEN

  WISE GRACE INVESTMENT LIMITED
(智喜投資有限公司)
1st Applicant
  READY EARN LIMITED
(韋迪有限公司)
2nd Applicant
  FORTUNE MOTION LIMITED
(聖維有限公司)
3rd Applicant
  and
  LUI MAN DUNG (雷文動) 1st Respondent
  LEE KA LEUNG (李嘉樑) 2nd Respondent
(Discontinued)
  LAM YIP YICK (林業億) 3rd Respondent
  ALLEN CHARLES WILLIAM 4th Respondent
(Discontinued)
  LIU CHING HEUNG (廖清香) by her guardian ad litem WONG CHUNG YAM (黃松欽) 5th Respondent
  LEUNG CHOI KAM (梁彩金) 6th Respondent
(Discontinued)
  BELCITY INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT LIMITED (麗拜國際發展有限公司) 7th Respondent
(Discontinued)

__________________________

Before: Her Honour Judge LJ Cruden, Presiding Officer of the Lands Tribunal, and
Mr Alex Ng, Member of the Lands Tribunal
Dates of Trial: 9-12 & 15-18 July 2024
Dates of Written Closing Submissions: 8 & 27 August 2024
Date of Judgment: 13 February 2025
Date of Corrigenda: 10 March 2025

_________________

CORRIGENDA

_________________


Please note the following corrections being made to the Judgment handed down on 13 February 2025 (the “Judgment”):

1.On page 61, in the 8th line from the top, the party “R5” should be corrected as “R3”.

2.On page 71, in the last line of paragraph 168, the 2 figures “$474,599,940” and “$322,413” should be corrected as “$473,140,083” and “$321,421” respectively.

3.On page 72, in the last 2 lines of paragraph 172, the 3 figures “$242,000,000”, “$89,411” and “$8,306” should be corrected as “$241,000,000”, “$89,042” and “$8,272” respectively.

4.On page 74, in the 5th line from the top (i.e. Order 4(b)), the reserve price “$242,000,000” should be corrected as “$241,000,000”.

5.The 2 tables, Appendix III and Appendix IV annexed to the Judgment, should be replaced by the 2 tables of the same titles respectively annexed hereto.


Dated this 10th day of March 2025

  (LI, Yuen-hop)
  Clerk to Member Alex NG
  For Clerk to Her Honour Judge LJ Cruden