China Shanshui Cement Group Ltd and Others v. Tianrui (International) Holding Company Ltd and Others
Case No.HCA 548/2019[2025] HKCFI 3893
Court
High Court CFI
Date02 Sep 2025
Judge—
Case Document
100%
HCA 548/2019 & HCA 1013/2023
(Heard together)
[2025] HKCFI 3893
HCA 548/2019
IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE
HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION
COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE
HIGH COURT ACTION NO 548 OF 2019
____________
BETWEEN
CHINA SHANSHUI CEMENT GROUP LIMITED
1st Plaintiff
(中國山水水泥集團有限公司)
CHINA SHANSHUI CEMENT GROUP (HONG KONG) COMPANY LIMITED
2nd Plaintiff
(中國山水水泥集團(香港)有限公司)
CHINA PIONEER CEMENT (HONG KONG) COMPANY LIMITED
3rd Plaintiff
SHANDONG SHANSHUI CEMENT GROUP COMPANY LIMITED
4th Plaintiff
and
TIANRUI (INTERNATIONAL) HOLDING COMPANY LIMITED
1st Defendant
TIANRUI GROUP COMPANY LIMITED
2nd Defendant
STEPHEN LIU YIU KEUNG (廖耀強)
3rd Defendant
DAVID YEN CHING WAI (閻正為)
4th Defendant
GODWIN HWA GUO WAI (華國威)
5th Defendant
CHONG CHA HWA (張家華)
6th Defendant
LI HEPING (李和平)
7th Defendant
LI LIUFA (李留法)
8th Defendant
CHEUNG YUK MING (張鈺明)
9th Defendant
NG QING HAI (黃清海)
10th Defendant
LI ZHIQIANG (李志強)
11th Defendant
HO MAN KAY, ANGELA (何文琪)
12th Defendant
LAW PUI CHEUNG (羅沛昌)
13th Defendant
WONG CHI KEUNG (黃之強)
14th Defendant
CHING SIU MING (程少明)
15th Defendant
LO CHUNG HING (盧重興)
16th Defendant
TSANG WING TAI (曾永泰)
17th Defendant
ERNST & YOUNG TRANSACTIONS LIMITED
18th Defendant
____________
AND
HCA 1013/2023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE
HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION
COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE
HIGH COURT ACTION NO 1013 OF 2023
____________
BETWEEN
TIANRUI GROUP COMPANY LIMITED
Plaintiff
(天瑞集團股份有限公司)
(a company incorporated in the People’s Republic of China)
and
CHINA SHANSHUI CEMENT GROUP LIMITED
1st Defendant
(中國山水水泥集團有限公司)
(a company incorporated in the Cayman Islands)
CHINA SHANSHUI CEMENT GROUP (HONG KONG) COMPANY LIMITED
2nd Defendant
(中國山水水泥集團(香港)有限公司)
CHINA PIONEER CEMENT (HONG KONG) COMPANY LIMITED
3rd Defendant
SHANDONG SHANSHUI CEMENT GROUP COMPANY LIMITED
4th Defendant
(山東山水水泥集團有限公司)
(a company incorporated in the People’s Republic of China)
____________
Before:
Deputy High Court Judge Andrew Li in Chambers
Date of Hearing:
30 April 2025
Date of Decision:
2 September 2025
_________________
CORRIGENDUM
_________________
1.Please note the following corrigenda in the Decision dated 2 September 2025: -
2.The instructing solicitors for the 1st to 4th defendants in HCA 1013/2023 are added between lines J and K on page 50. The end of the page should read “Mr Victor Dawes SC leading Ms Bonnie Cheng and Mr Harrison Miao, jointly instructed by C Y Tsang & Co for the 1st to 4th plaintiffs in HCA 548/2019 and by Woo Kwan Lee & Lo for the 1st to 4th defendants in HCA 1013/2023”.
Dated this 10th day of September 2025
(Jamie Wong)
Clerk to Deputy High Court Judge Andrew Li
Summaries and metadata are generated from the judgment. Report an error