Kerryford Holdings Ltd and Others v. Profit Valley Ltd and Others

Read the full judgment text of LDCS 8000/2022 on BabelCite. This LDCS judgment was delivered on 12 December 2025.

1. In paragraph 33, “judgment” should read as “decision”.

Cites 1 case

Case No.LDCS 8000/2022
Court
LDCS
Date12 Dec 2025
Judge
Case Document
100%Judiciary

LDCS 8000/2022

[2025] HKLdT 75

IN THE LANDS TRIBUNAL OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

LAND COMPULSORY SALE MAIN APPLICATION NO. 8000 OF 2022

__________________________

BETWEEN

  KERRYFORD HOLDINGS LIMITED 1st Applicant
  TIME PILOT LIMITED 2nd Applicant
  RECORD MASTER LIMITED 3rd Applicant
  MAPLE HARVEST HOLDINGS LIMITED 4th Applicant
  MAGICAL YEAR LIMITED (佳歲有限公司) 5th Applicant
  GLOBAL CHINA INVESTMENT LIMITED 6th Applicant
  (邦華投資有限公司)  
  TOP HONOR INTERNATIONAL TRADING LIMITED 7th Applicant
  (高信國際貿易有限公司)  
  PRIMERICH INTERNATIONAL LIMITED 8th Applicant
  (旭百國際有限公司)  
  CONNAUGHT INTERNATIONAL (HK) LIMITED 9th Applicant
  (康樂國際(香港)有限公司)  
  FRUITFUL LUCK INVESTMENT DEVELOPMENT LIMITED (富祥投資發展有限公司) 10th Applicant
  FULL SHINE INC LIMITED (逸旭有限公司) 11th Applicant
  GRAND POWER INTERNATIONAL LIMITED 12th Applicant
  (百力國際有限公司)  
  BEST JOY INDUSTRIAL LIMITED 13th Applicant
  (佳樂實業有限公司)  
  CORPORATE KING LIMITED (浩皇有限公司) 14th Applicant
  BEST PARTNERS INVESTMENT DEVELOPMENT LIMITED (栢盈投資發展有限公司) 15th Applicant
  MILLION RICH STAR LIMITED (萬富星有限公司) 16th Applicant
  EXPRESS WEALTH HONG KONG INVESTMENT LIMITED (捷富香港投資有限公司) 17th Applicant
  TOP GRADE INC LIMITED (上灝有限公司) 18th Applicant
  BEAM INC LIMITED (翹暉有限公司) 19th Applicant
  and  
  WINRISE CORPORATION LIMITED 1st Respondent
  (永昇達有限公司) (Discontinued)
  PROFIT VALLEY LIMITED (青雅有限公司) 2nd Respondent
  CIRCLE PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT LIMITED 3rd Respondent
  (永光地產發展有限公司) (Discontinued)
  CHU WAI MING CALVIN (朱偉明) 4th Respondent
  CHU WAI CHOI ROBERT (朱偉才) 5th Respondent
  CHU WAI LUN TONY (朱偉倫) also known as CHU, TONY (朱偉倫) 6th Respondent
  LI KIT SHEUNG (李潔嫦) 7th Respondent
  LAI CHI CHOI PHILIP (黎智財) 8th Respondent
  LAI WAI YING MARGARET (黎慧瑩) 9th Respondent
  LAI WEI SUM NORA (黎慧心) 10th Respondent
  SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE 11th Respondent (Discontinued)
  CHAN YIP SHAM (陳業森) 12th Respondent
  alias: CHAN MAN YUK (陳文玉)  
  HOM SHE HEN (譚素軒) 13th Respondent
  CHEUNG HON CHU (張漢柱), the Executor of the Will of KONG SHIH HENG (江雪 ) also known as KONG SHIH HENG (江雪卿) (deceased) 14th Respondent
  CMB WING LUNK BANK LIMITED 15th Respondent
  (招商永隆銀行有限公司)  
  TWIN WIN DEVELOPMENT LIMITED 16th Respondent
  (優冠發展有限公司)  
  KWONG PING KUEN (鄺炳權), guardian ad litem of KWONG WAI PIU (鄺偉標) 17th Respondent (Discontinued)
  CHENG KAM NGOR (鄭錦娥) 18th Respondent
  CELESTIAL STAR INVESTMENT LIMITED 19th Respondent
  MAK SAU KUEN AMY (麥秀娟) 20th Respondent
  LIM SZE SING (林士昇) 21st Respondent
  MAK KIN WAH KEN (麥健華) 22nd Respondent
  KWOK HEUNG KUM (郭香琴) 23rd Respondent
  CHEUNG KEE MEE HEUNG YUEN GROUP LIMITED (祥記美香園集團有限公司) 24th Respondent
  LEE YEE HUNG (李綺紅), the Administratrix of the estate of KOO KAM HUNG (顧錦鴻), deceased 25th Respondent (Discontinued)
  KOO KAM FU (顧錦富), the Administrator of the estate of KOO KAM HOI, deceased 26th Respondent (Discontinued)
  ETERNAL COSMOS INTERNATIONAL LIMITED 27th Respondent
  (永富安國際有限公司)  
  LEE YEUK SZE (李若詩), the Administratrix of the estate of LI (or LEE) FU WAH (李富華), deceased 28th Respondent
  LI CHIU TAI alias: LIE TJIOE THAY (李朝泰) 29th Respondent
  KWAN HING WAH alias: KWAN HENG HOA (關慶華) 30th Respondent
  KWAN HON KEUNG alias: KWAN HAN KIONG 31st Respondent
  (關漢強)  
  THE INCORPORATED OWNERS OF HAPPY MANSION (快樂大廈業主立案法團) 32nd Respondent
  WILSON DEVELOPMENT COMPANY LIMITED 33rd Respondent
  (景成發展有限公司)  
  WONG WING CHIU (黃榮釗), also known as WONG WING CHIU, WARWICK (黃榮釗) 34th Respondent
  TSUI KAR YIN, AMY (徐嘉賢) 35th Respondent
    (Discontinued)
  LAM SAI WING (林世榮), the Executor of the estate of YU FUNG KAM (余鳳金), deceased 36th Respondent
  CHEERFUL INVESTMENT DEVELOPMENT LIMITED (智富投資發展有限公司) 37th Respondent (Discontinued)
  JILL HUIRONG LEUNG as the Trustee of THE LEUNG FAMILY TRUST 38th Respondent
  TOP ACTIVE LIMITED (冠港有限公司) 39th Respondent
  YAN YAN MOTORS LIMITED (人人汽車有限公司) 40th Respondent
  IP KWONG LEUNG (葉光良) 41st Respondent (Discontinued)
  RISE WEALTH ENTERPRISE LIMITED 42nd Respondent
  (寶晉企業有限公司)  
  WAN HING (温興) 43rd Respondent
  WONG SHUI KIU (黃瑞嬌) 44th Respondent
  CHING WING YEE WINNIE (程詠儀) 45th Respondent (Discontinued)
  TJONG FON FAT (張煥發) (otherwise known as RUSTAM SOFIAN) 46th Respondent
  THE REGISTRAR OF COMPANIES 47th Respondent (Discontinued)
  JOHN TSEE CHUNG CHIN (陳子中) 48th Respondent
  CHAN FAI YUEN (陳輝元) 49th Respondent
  EUGENE CHIN (陳友仁) 50th Respondent
  CHAN WAI YEE 51st Respondent
    (Discontinued)

Before: Her Honour Judge LJ Cruden, Presiding Officer of the Lands Tribunal, and Mr Lawrence Pang, Member of the Lands Tribunal
Dates of Hearing: 15 October 2025
Date of Decision: 12 December 2025
Date of Corrigendum: 5 January 2026

__________________

CORRIGENDUM

__________________

Please note the following corrigendum in the Decision dated 12 December 2025:

1.In paragraph 33, “judgment” should read as “decision”.


Dated this 5th day of January 2026

  (Cardio TZE)
Clerk to Member Lawrence PANG,
Lands Tribunal