Case Document

100%

CACV 77/2024, [2026] HKCA 632

On Appeal From [2024] HKCFI 331

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF APPEAL

CIVIL APPEAL NO 77 OF 2024

(ON APPEAL FROM HCAL NO 946 OF 2019 and 1007 OF 2019)

_______________

RE:	SHAHUL HAMEED BEER MOHAMED	1^st Applicant
	MUNAWAROH	2^nd Applicant
	JULIA SAFIRA, a minor, by her next friend and mother MUNAWAROH	3^rd Applicant
	MUNAWAROH SAHIRA, a minor, by her next friend and mother MUNAWAROH	4^th Applicant
	MUNAWAROH SAFINA, a minor, by her next friend and mother MUNAWAROH	5^th Applicant
	SHAHUL HAMEED SAL SABILLA, a minor, by her next friend and mother MUNAWAROH	6^th Applicant
	SHAHUL HAMEED SAL SHAHANA, a minor, by her next friend and father SHAHUL HAMEED BEER MOHAMED	7^th Applicant

_______________

Before:

Hon Au and G. Lam JJA in Court

Date of Hearing:	28 November 2024
Date of Judgment:	8 April 2026
Date of Corrigendum:	19 August 2026

________________________

C O R R I G E N D U M

________________________

Please note the following corrigendum in the Judgment dated 8 April 2026:

1.The title of the judgment should read as follows:

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF APPEAL

CIVIL APPEAL NO 77 OF 2024

(ON APPEAL FROM HCAL NO 946 OF 2019 and 1007 OF 2019

(CONSOLIDATED))

_______________

HCAL 946/2019

_______________

BETWEEN
	MUNAWAROH	1^stApplicant
	SHAHUL HAMEED BEER MOHAMED	2^nd Applicant
	SHAHUL HAMEED JULIA SAFIRA, a minor, by her next friend and mother MUNAWAROH	3^rd Applicant
	MUNAWAROH SAHIRA, a minor, by her next friend and mother MUNAWAROH	4^th Applicant
	MUNAWAROH SAFINA, a minor, by her next friend and mother MUNAWAROH	5^th Applicant
	SHAHUL HAMEED SAL SABILLA, a minor, by her next friend and mother MUNAWAROH	6^th Applicant
	and
	TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE	Putative Respondent
	and
	DIRECTOR OF IMMIGRATION	Putative Interested Party

_______________

and

HCAL 1007/2019

_______________

BETWEEN
	SHAHUL HAMEED BEER MOHAMED	1^stApplicant
	SHAHUL HAMEED SAL SHAHANA, a minor, by her next friend and father SHAHUL HAMEED BEER MOHAMED	2^nd Applicant
	and
	TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE	Putative Respondent
	and
	DIRECTOR OF IMMIGRATION	Putative Interested Party

_______________

(Consolidated pursuant to the Order of
Deputy High Court Judge K.W. Lung dated 24 August 2023)

2.On page 3, paragraph 5, “The applicants are members of a family. The 1^st and 2^nd applicants are respectively the father (“the Father”) and the mother (“the Mother”) (collectively “the Parents”). The 3^rd to 6^th applicants are their elder daughters (“the Elder Daughters”) and the 7^th applicant their youngest daughter (“the Youngest Daughter”) (collectively “the Daughters”).” should read as “The applicants are members of a family. The 1^st and 2^nd applicants in HCAL 946 are respectively the mother (“the Mother”) and the father (“the Father”) (collectively “the Parents”). The 3^rd to 6^th applicants in HCAL 946 are their elder daughters (“the Elder Daughters”) and the 2^nd applicant in HCAL 1007 is their youngest daughter (“the Youngest Daughter”) (collectively “the Daughters”).”.

3.On page 26, paragraph 69, “For the above reasons, we dismiss the 1^st to 7^th applicants’ appeal.” should read as “For the above reasons, we dismiss the applicants’ appeal.”.

4.On page 26, line N, “Albert N B Wong, assigned by the Director of Legal Aid, for the 1^st to 7^th applicants” should read as “Albert N B Wong, assigned by the Director of Legal Aid, for the applicants.

(Yuko LOO)
for Registrar, High Court

Cites 2 cases

Cases cited in this judgment

Munawaroh and Others v. Torture Claims Appeal Board / Non-refoulement Claims Petition Office

[2024] HKCFI 331 · High Court CFI

23 Feb 2024

Re Shahul Hameed Beer Mohamed and Others

CACV 77/2024 · Court of Appeal

08 Apr 2026

Related Cases

Ranked by citation overlap · cases that cite each other appear first