Pang Chong Yip and Pang Kwai Choy As Managers and Members of ‘pang Nam Hing Tong’ v. Lui Chan Man Alex and Others

Case No.DCCJ 949/2025[2026] HKDC 1313
Court
District Court
Date20 Jul 2026
Judge
Case Document
100%

DCCJ 949/2025

[2026] HKDC 1313

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

CIVIL ACTION NO 949 OF 2025

---------------------------------------

BETWEEN

  PANG CHONG YIP (彭創業) and PANG KWAI
CHOY (彭貴財) as Managers and Members of
‘PANG NAM HING TONG’ (彭南慶堂)
Plaintiff
and
  LUI CHAN MAN ALEX 1st Defendant
  PANG YING KAI 2nd Defendant
  彭土祥 3rd Defendant
  SHAM WAI CHAY 4th Defendant
  劉萍 5th Defendant
  ALL UNKNOWN OCCUPIERS OF THE
REMAINING PROTION OF SECTION B OF
TAXLORD LOT NO. T4 IN DEMARCATION
DISTRICT NO. 51
6th Defendant
  PANG KWOK KIT彭國傑 7th Defendant

---------------------------------------

Before: Deputy District Judge Gekko Lan in Chambers
Date of Hearing: 4 March 2026
Date of Decision: 20 July 2026
Date of Corrigendum: 21 August 2026

--------------------------

CORRIGENDUM

--------------------------

Notice is hereby given that the following amendments be made to the Decision:-

1.Page 12, line Q, “is” should read as “are”.

2.Page 13, line I, “see” should read as “sell”.

3.Page 18, line G, “where designing trustees is acting in breach of trust and refusing to join in the proceedings or, no doubt, where are the special circumstances apply” should read as “where the dissenting trustee is acting in breach of trust in refusing to join in the proceedings or, no doubt, where other special circumstances apply”.

4.Page 19, line L, “whether the Lease, even if accords with the Pleaded Custom” should read as “whether the lease, even if accords with the pleaded custom”.

5.Page 19, line P, “fropm each of tej” should read as “from each of the”.

6.Page 21, line M, “Ds’ Claim” should read as “P’s claim”.

7.Page 22, line C & D, “I am unable to conclude that. that the Plaintiff’s claim against D7 is bound to fail” should read as “I am unable to conclude that the Plaintiff’s claim against D7 is bound to fail”.

  ( Gekko Lan )
  Deputy District Judge