Read the full judgment text of HCCT 40/1999 on BabelCite. This 高等法院原訟法庭 judgment was delivered on 8 November 2000 before Hon Burrell J.
Contract Law — Construction and Arbitration — Sub-contracting — Scope and terms of contract — Back-to-back and pay-when-paid terms — Repudiatory breach — Failure to fund project — Assessment of damages — Profit and lost opportunity — Interest and costs. The plaintiff, Wo Hing Engineering Limited, was awarded a fixed price electrical installation sub-contract for $80 million and sub-contracted the works to the defendant, Tyco Engineering & Construction (Hong Kong) Limited, for a fixed 3% fee. Tyco commenced works before formal documentation and was to finance the project. Funding difficulties within Tyco's Hong Kong management and Singapore head office led to delayed payments to suppliers and labour, causing project delays and frustration. The court found a contract existed incorporating back-to-back terms with the main contract and that Tyco repudiated the contract by failing to provide necessary funding, frustrating the contract’s commercial purpose. Wo Hing resumed control of the works, chose to complete the project itself, and claimed damages for loss of profit and fees. The court adopted a broad methodology assessing damages based on a 10% profit margin on the whole contract, including the lost 3% fee, to place Wo Hing in the position it would have been without Tyco's repudiation. The court rejected the claim for loss of future business beyond the contract. Interest was awarded on sums due and costs ordered mostly in favour of Wo Hing. The defendant appealed the quantum of damages, and the Court of Appeal remitted the matter for fresh determination. The judgment sets a significant analysis of contractual interpretation and repudiation in construction sub-contracting and the assessment of related damages.
Legal issues: Nature and terms of the contract between Wo Hing and Tyco · Whether Tyco repudiated the contract · Appropriate methodology for assessing damages · Claim for loss of business
Outcome: Judgment for Wo Hing; Tyco held in repudiatory breach and liable for damages calculated on a 10% profit basis plus lost 3% fee and agreed claims for seconded staff; interest awarded.
Cites 1 case