|
CACV000079CM/1988
| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL |
Civil Appeal
|
|
No 79 of 1988
|
BETWEEN
|
IP (OR YIP) CHEUNG (OR CHING ) KWOK (also known as DAVID IP or YIP) for himself and as the person appointed to represent the Estate of Ip KOO CHI deceased |
Plaintiff
(1st Respondent) |
|
|
|
|
AND
|
|
|
|
|
|
Ip Siu Bun |
1st Refendant |
|
|
(2nd Defendant) |
|
Ip Cheung Kit Yee |
2nd Defendant |
|
|
(3rd Respondent) |
|
Ip Siu Kong (or Kwong) |
3rd Defendant |
|
Sin Hua bank Trustee Limited |
4th Defendant |
|
|
(Appellant) |
|
(by original action )
|
|
AND BETWEEN
|
Sin Hua bank Trustee Limited |
Plaintiff
|
|
|
(Appellant)
|
|
|
|
|
AND
|
|
|
|
|
|
Ip (or Yip) CHEUNG or (CHIANG) Kwok (also known as DAVID IP or Yip) for himself and as the person appointed to represent the Estate of Ip Koo Chi deceased |
1st Defendant
(1st respondent)
|
|
The Attorney General |
2nd Defendant
|
|
|
(4th Respondent)
|
|
Ip Siu Bun |
3rd Defendant
|
|
|
(2nd Respondent
|
|
(by counterclaim)
|
|
______________
Coram: Hon. Cons, V-P., Kempster & Clough, JJ.A.
Date of Handing Down: 28 November 1989
--------------------------------------------------------------------
2ND JUDGMENT ON PRELIMINARY ISSUES
--------------------------------------------------------------------
CORRIGENDUM
On page 3, the last sixth line, the date of " 22 May 1899" should read as " 22 May 1989 ".
|
( Peter CHEUNG)
|
|
Clerk to Hon. Kempster, J.A
|
|
14.5.90
|
|