Man Ping Nam v. Man Mei Kwai

Case No.CACV 193/2002

Court

Court of Appeal

Date11 Dec 2002

Judge—

Case Document

100%

CACV000193M/2002

CACV 193/2002

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF APPEAL

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 193 OF 2002

(ON APPEAL FROM HCA NO. 9852 OF 1998)

____________________

BETWEEN
	MAN PING NAM, the manager of MAN SHAM CHUNG WUI	Plaintiff

	AND

	MAN MEI KWAI (by original action)	Defendant

____________________

AND BETWEEN
	MAN MEI KWAI	Plaintiff

	AND

	MAN PING NAM as manager of MAN SHAM CHUNG WUI	1st Defendant
	LO CHI WAI (盧志偉),	2nd Defendants
	LEUNG YAU SING (梁有勝),
	KO FUK SING (高福勝),
	CHOW HING FUK(周興福),
	KWOK MUK TAI(郭木泰),
	KWAN CHI KEUNG (關志強),
	LEUNG CHAK KONG (梁擇光),
	KWOK KAM FUK (郭金福) and
	KWOK YUN CHEUNG (郭潤祥)
	(by counterclaim)

____________________

Coram: Hon Le Pichon, Cheung JJA and Stone J in Court

Date of Hearing: 8-9 October 2002

Date of Handing Down of Judgment: 11 December 2002

_________________

CORRIGENDUM

_________________

On page 19 - The fifth line of paragraph 19 should read "(ii) the declaration ought not to have been granted because there was no lis between the parties;"