Lai Yu v. The Director of Lands

Read the full judgment text of LDLR 6/1999 on BabelCite. This Lands Tribunal judgment was delivered on 10 May 2000.

Case No.LDLR 6/1999
Court
Lands Tribunal
Date10 May 2000
Judge
Case Document
100%Judiciary

LDLR000006M/1999

LDLR6/1999

IN THE LANDS TRIBUNAL OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

Application No.: LDLR No.6 of 1999

BETWEEN
Lai Yu (Applicant)
AND
The Director of Lands (Respondent)

Coram: Member W K LO

Dates of Hearing: 17 April 2000

Date of Judgment: 10 May 2000

__________________

Corrigendum

__________________

Please note that pages 6, 12, 13, 14 & 15 of the Judgment dated 10 May 2000 have the following amendments:-

(1) At page 6, in the 3rd line of the last paragraph under the paragraph "Applicant's evidence and submission", delete the word of "Respondent" and is amended by the word "Applicant";

(2) At page 12, under the paragraph of "Adjustments of chosen comparables". In the table, under the "Parties" column, amendments are as follows:-

(i) Item 6 - lst line, delete the word of "Applicant" and is amended by the word of "Respondent";
2nd line, delete the word of "Respondent" and is amended by the word of "Applicant";
(ii) Item 8 - lst line, delete the word of "Applicant" and is amended by the word of "Respondent";
2nd line, delete the word of "Respondent" and is amended by the word of "Applicant";
(iii) Item 10 - lst line, delete the word of "Applicant" and is amended by the word of "Respondent";
2nd line, delete the word of "Respondent" and is amended by the word of "Applicant";
(iv) Item 11 -

lst line, delete the word of "Applicant" and is amended by the word of "Respondent";

2nd line, delete the word of "Respondent" and is amended by the word of "Applicant"; and

(v) Item 12 -

lst line, delete the word of "Applicant" and is amended by the word of "Respondent";

2nd line, delete the word of "Respondent" and is amended by the word of "Applicant".

(3) At page 13, under the sub-paragraph "Shape", amendments are as follows:-

(i) In the 3rd line, delete the word of "Applicant" and is amended by the word of "Respondent"; and

(ii) In the 4th line, delete the word of "Respondent" and is amended by the word of "Applicant"

.(4)(A) At page 14, under sub-paragraph of "Right of Way", amendments are as follows:-

(i) In the 13th line of the 1st paragraph, delete the word of "upward" and is amended by the word of "downward"; and

(ii) In the 1st line of the 2nd paragraph, delete "+5%" and is amended by "-5%".

(B) At page 14, under sub-paragraph of "Effect of Overhead Power Line", in the 2nd line, delete the word of"Applicant" and is amended by the word of "Respondent"; and

(5) At page 15, under the paragraph "Tribunal's valuation", last line delete the word of "Respondent" and is amended by the word of "Applicant".

Dated 29 June 2000

(W.K. Lo)
Member, Lands Tribunal

Other Judgments in This Case

Further hearings and rulings under LDLR 6/1999