Wong Leung Chi v. Luen Fat Civil Engineering Ltd and Another

Read the full judgment text of HCPI 975/2002 on BabelCite. This High Court CFI judgment.

1. Judgment was delivered in this matter on 25 August 2004.  In paragraph 38 of the judgment I set out a summary of the damages award.  The parties have now drawn attention to the fact that there were certain errors in that summary.  The parties have, sensibly, agreed the correct summary which I now set out.

Case No.HCPI 975/2002
Court
High Court CFI
Date
Judge
Case Document
100%Judiciary

HCPI975/2002

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

PERSONAL INJURIES ACTION NO. 975 OF 2002

____________

BETWEEN

  WONG LEUNG CHI Plaintiff
  and  
  LUEN FAT CIVIL ENGINEERING LIMITED 1st Defendant
  YIU WING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY 2nd Defendant
  LIMITED (in liquidation)  
  and  
  TRIFAIRCO ENGINEERING COMPANY LIMITED Third Party

____________

Before: Deputy High Court JudgeSaunders in Court

_____________

CORRIGENDA

_____________

1.Judgment was delivered in this matter on 25 August 2004.  In paragraph 38 of the judgment I set out a summary of the damages award.  The parties have now drawn attention to the fact that there were certain errors in that summary.  The parties have, sensibly, agreed the correct summary which I now set out.

2.Summary of damages awarded:

  PSLA HK$400,000.00  
  Pre-trial loss of earnings 780,500.00  
  Pre-trial loss of MPF 27,900.00  
  Future loss of earnings 324,000.00  
  Agreed special damages 29,686.00  
  Further special damages 5,000.00  
  Future medical expenses 12,000.00  
  Interest 139,439.00  
LESS compensation paid to the Plaintiff by    
  The Defendant in DCEC 692 of 2001 192,100.00  
  Judgement for the Plaintiff: 1,526,425.00  

3.By consent, the costs of the action after the plaintiff, to be taxed on a party in party basis if not agreed, with the Plaintiff's costs to be taxed in accordance with Legal Aid Regulations.

   (John Saunders)
  Deputy High Court Judge

Ms Phillis Loh (16 & 17 August 2002), instructed by Messrs Donald Yap, Cheng & Kong, for the Plaintiff

Mr Dennis Law instructed by Messrs W K To & Co., for the 1st and 2nd Defendants

Mr Andy Hung instructed by Messrs Pansy Leung, Tang & Chua, for the Third Party

Other Judgments in This Case

Further hearings and rulings under HCPI 975/2002