Ever Harvest Tobacco and Liquor Bonded Warehouse Ltd v. Force 8 Cellars Ltd

Case No.DCCJ 1945/2007
Court
District Court
Date06 Feb 2009
Judge
Case Document
100%

DCCJ 1945/2007

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

CIVIL ACTION NO. 1945 OF 2007

----------------------

BETWEEN    
  EVER HARVEST TOBACCO AND  LIQUOR BONDED WAREHOUSE LIMITED
(永誠烟酒保稅倉有限公司)
Plaintiff
  and  
    FORCE 8 CELLARS LIMTIED Defendant

----------------------

Coram: H.H. Judge Chow

Date of handing down Judgment:   6th February 2009

----------------------

Corrigendum

----------------------

Paragraph 34 at page 18 is amended as follows: -

“34.   Item 13 is based on Invoices from AZA Cargo in respect of the removal of the Defendant’s inventory from the bonded warehouse as a result of the Plaintiff’s failure to assign staff to receive, sort and package in accordance with Clauses 1.7 and 1.8 of the Agreement.  The Agreement no longer operated since November 2005.  So the legal basis for this claim has gone.  There is no evidence to show that the Defendant has paid the alleged amount.  There is no evidence to show that the costs were incurred due to the fault of the Plaintiff.  So this claim must fail.”

Dated this 2nd of June 2009

   (S. Chow)
District Judge