Wong Luen Hang and Another v. Chan Yuk Lung and Others

HCA 2654/2007

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

ACTION NO. 2654 OF 2007

________________________

BETWEEN

________________________

Before : Hon Sakhrani J in Chambers

Date of Order : 5 January 2011

Date of Plaintiffs’ statement of costs : 10 January 2011

Date of Defendants’ objections : 19 January 2011

Date of Summary Assessment of Costs : 26 January 2011

_________________________________

SUMMARY ASSESSMENT OF COSTS

_________________________________

1.This is the summary assessment of the costs order I made on 5 January 2011 in relation to the plaintiffs’ application by summons filed on 9 November 2010. The costs order made was that the costs of the application be to the plaintiffs to be summarily assessed.

2.It is well established that in conducting a summary assessment of costs the Court adopts a broad-brush approach.  It is not a mini taxation of costs.

3.I have considered the plaintiffs’ statement of costs and the defendant’s objections.  The total amount claimed is $206,064 as particularized in the statement of costs. 

4.As to item C1 it seems to me that the time spent was excessive.

5.As to item D1 I consider that the time spent on preparation of documents was also excessive.

6.As to item E in respect of counsel’s fees, it seems to me that the time spent on conferences with counsel was excessive.

7.Taking a broad-brush approach I would summarily assess the costs of the application to the plaintiff in the total sum of $170,064. 

8.I order that the said sum of $170,064 be paid by the defendants to the plaintiffs within 14 days from today.

Messrs Lee Chan Cheng for the 1^st and 2^nd Plaintiffs

Messrs Wong Poon Chan Law & Co. for the 1^st to 3^rd Defendants