Case Document

100%Judiciary

DCCJ 2642/2012

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

CIVIL ACTION NO. 2642 OF 2012

_________________________

BETWEEN

	CHEUNG CHURK HUNG (張焯雄)	1^st Plaintiff
	CITY CHAMPION MANAGEMENT LIMITED	2^nd Plaintiff
	And
	Mok Chi Cheong (莫志昌)	1^st Defendant
	Mok Fok Nan (莫福能)	2^nd Defendant
	Cheung Kam Fok (張錦福)	3^rd Defendant
	Man Lau Fong (文流芳)	4^th Defendant
	Man Chun Heung (文仲香)	5^th Defendant
	Mok Fok Wai (莫福維)	6^th Defendant
	Cheung Kwok Tai (張國泰)	7^th Defendant
	Lok Man Fat (駱萬發)	8^th Defendant
	Cheung Kam Cheong (張錦昌)	9^th Defendant
	Cheung Choi Lan (張彩蘭)	10^th Defendant
	Mok Wai Hung (莫偉雄)	11^th Defendant
	Man Siu Kei (文紹基)	12^th Defendant
	Man Kwai Hing (文貴興)	13^th Defendant
	Cheung Ka Hing (張家慶)	14^th Defendant
	Cheung Kwong Yiu (張廣耀)	15^th Defendant
	Man Cheong Lam (文暢林)	16^th Defendant
	Cheung Cho Wong (張祖旺)	17^th Defendant
	Cheung King Chu (張景柱)	18^th Defendant
	Mok Chi Fu (莫志富)	19^th Defendant
	Man Siu Lam (文蕭林)	20^th Defendant
	Lau Shui Kin (劉瑞堅)	21^st Defendant
	Mok Hay Man (莫熙文)	22^nd Defendant

_________________________

Before: His Honour Judge Kent Yee in Chambers (Open to Public)

Dates of Hearing: 27 February 2013

Date of Judgment: 29 April 2013

Parties: Miss Lorinda Lau instructed by Messrs Paul W. Tse for the plaintiffs

Mr Simon Yip instructed by Messrs Raymond Chan & Kenneth Yuen & Co.for the defendants

-----------------------------

CORRIGENDUM

-----------------------------

Notice is hereby given that the following amendments be made to the judgment of 29 April 2013:-

1. page 2, para 2, line 11, delete the words “, unlawful interference with the use and enjoyment of the Land”;

2. page 6, para 18, line 2, insert the word “to” after the word “belong”;

3. page 6, para 19, line 6, delete the word “in”, insert the word “to” ;

4. page 7, para 20, line 2, delete the word “on”, insert the word “of” ;

5. page 8, para 27, line 6, insert the word “Court” after the word “High”;

6. page 9, para 30, line 2, insert the word “throughout” after the word “Action”;

7. page 9, para 31, line 2, delete the word “Order”, insert the words “Writ of Possession” ;

8. page 10, para 32, line 4, delete the words “are making”, insert the word “made” ;

9. page 10, para 32, line 5, insert the words “in October 2012” after the word “time”;

10. page 10, para 33, line 6, delete the word “counterclaims”, insert the word “counterclaim” ;

11. page 10, para 34, line 3, delete the word “refraining”, insert the word “refrain” ;

12. page 10, para 35, line 4, delete the word “follows”, insert the word “follow” ;

13. page 10, para 36, line 2, insert the word “and” after the word “trespass,”;

14. page 10, para 36, lines 2-3, delete the words “and unlawful interference”;

15. page 10, para 36, line 3, insert the word “he” after the word “unfortunately”;

16. page 12, para 41, line 4, delete the words “there is”, insert the words “I find” ;

17. page 13, para 44, line 5, delete the word “injunctions”, insert the word “injunction” ;

18. page 13, para 47, line 3, delete the word “was”, insert the word “is” ;

19. page 14, para 51, line 1, insert the words “it is clear to me that” before the words “all other defendants”;

20. page 14, para 51, lines 1-2, delete the words “appear to have”;

21. page 14, para 51, line 2, delete the words “to work”, insert the words “from working” .

Dated the 30^th day of April, 2013

( Kent Yee )
District Judge

Cites 1 case

Cases cited in this judgment

Cheung Churk Hung and Another v. Mok Chi Cheong and Others

DCCJ 2642/2012

District Court29 Apr 2013

Other Judgments in This Case

Further hearings and rulings under DCCJ 2642/2012

Cheung Churk Hung and Another v. Mok Chi Cheong and Others

District Court29 Apr 2013

Cheung Churk Hung and Another v. Mok Chi Cheong and Others

District Court16 Aug 2012