Case Document

100%

HCMP 1790/2016
and
HCMP 1791/2016

[2021] HKCFI 47

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

MISCELLANEOUS PROCEEDINGS NO. 1790 OF 2016

________________________

	IN THE MATTER SECTION 33 OF THE PROBATE AND ADMINISTRATION ORDINANCE (CAP 10) AND ORDER 85 RULE 2 OF THE RULES OF HIGH COURT
	and
	IN THE MATTER of the Estate of TSUI YUEN YING (徐婉英) also spelt as ZEE WON ING (徐婉英) also spelt as ZEE WONG ING (徐婉英) also known as TSUI SAN MUI (徐姍梅), deceased (the Deceased)

________________________

BETWEEN

	CHANG WING KA JOHN	Applicant
	and
	CHANG WING DEE (in his capacity as an administrator of the estate of TSUI YUEN YING (徐婉英) (also spelt as ZEE WON ING (徐婉英) also spelt as ZEE WONG ING (徐婉英) also known as TSUI SAN MUI (徐姍梅), deceased)	1^st Respondent
	HU ESTHER YUNG MAY	2^nd Respondent

________________________

MISCELLANEOUS PROCEEDINGS NO. 1791 OF 2016

________________________

	IN THE MATTER SECTION 33 OF THE PROBATE AND ADMINISTRATION ORDINANCE (CAP 10) AND ORDER 85 RULE 2 OF THE RULES OF HIGH COURT
	and
	IN THE MATTER of the Estate of CHANG YIN CHING (張寅青), deceased (the Deceased)

________________________

BETWEEN

	CHANG WING KA JOHN	Applicant
	and
	CHANG WING DEE (in his capacity as an administrator of the estate of CHANG YIN CHING (張寅青), deceased)	1^st Respondent
	HU ESTHER YUNG MAY	2^nd Respondent

(Consolidated by the Order of the Honourable Mr. Justice Chow dated 31 August 2016)

________________________

Before:

Deputy High Court Judge To in Court

Dates of Trial:	16-18, 21-23 & 30 September 2020
Date of Judgment:	11 January 2020

________________________

CORRIGENDUM

________________________

Please note the following amendment in the Judgment dated 11 January 2020:

1.The Date of Judgment on page 2 be amended to read as follow:

“ 11 January 2021 ”

Dated the 2^nd day of February 2021

	(WU Sin Mei, Sammi)
	Clerk to Deputy High Court Judge To

Cites 2 cases

Cases cited in this judgment

Chang Wing Ka John v. Chang Wing Dee

[2021] HKCFI 47 · High Court CFI

11 Jan 2020

Full analysis

Chang Wing Ka John v. Chang Wing Dee and Another

HCMP 1790/2016 · High Court CFI

11 Jan 2020

Full analysis

Related Cases

Ranked by citation overlap · cases that cite each other appear first

Kan Yuk Sum v. Kan Yuk Shing (in His Personal Capacity and As the Executor of the Estate of Tam Lee Yau)

HCMP 268/2023 · High Court CFI

26 Jun 2025

cites this

Cited by 19 cases

Other judgments that cite this case

Ng Sau Lin and Another v. An Ki, in Her Personal Capacity and As the Sole Administratrix of the Estate of Sze Wang Chak, Deceased

High Court CFI

03 Feb 2026

Chan Chu Wa and Another v. Chan Chau Fung, The Administratrix of the Estate of Poon Siu Chun, Deceased and Others

Court of First Instance

12 Nov 2025

Full analysis

Chan Sun Judy v. Qin Xiaojian, The Sole Administrator of the Estate of Chan Wai Hing Alexander, Deceased

High Court CFI

04 Nov 2025

Kan Yuk Sum v. Kan Yuk Shing (in His Personal Capacity and As the Executor of the Estate of Tam Lee Yau)

High Court CFI

26 Jun 2025

Other Judgments in This Case

Further hearings and rulings under HCMP 1790/2016

Chang Wing Ka John v. Chang Wing Dee and Another

High Court CFI

11 Jan 2020

Full analysis

Chang Wing Ka John v. Chang Wing Dee and Another

High Court CFI

11 Jan 2020

Chang Wing Ka John v. Chang Wing Dee and Another

High Court CFI

30 Dec 2025

Chang Wing Ka John v. Chang Wing Dee and Another

High Court CFI

30 Dec 2025

Chang Wing Ka John v. Chang Wing Dee and Another

High Court CFI

06 May 2026

Chang Wing Ka John v. Chang Wing Dee and Another

High Court CFI

06 May 2026

Chang Wing Ka John v. Chang Wing Dee

Chang Wing Ka John v. Chang Wing Dee and Another

Chang Wing Ka John v. Chang Wing Dee and Another

Chang Wing Ka John v. Chang Wing Dee and Another

Kan Yuk Sum v. Kan Yuk Shing (in His Personal Capacity and As the Executor of the Estate of Tam Lee Yau)

Ng Sau Lin and Another v. An Ki, in Her Personal Capacity and As the Sole Administratrix of the Estate of Sze Wang Chak, Deceased

Chu Wing Chuen Paul and Others v. Chu Oi Yan Irene

Kan Yuk Sum v. Kan Yuk Shing (in His Personal Capacity and As the Executor of the Estate of Tam Lee Yau)

Law Wai Hay v. Law Po Chong Priscilla, The Administratrix of the Estate of Cheung Wai Fun, Deceased

Ng Kit, The Legal Representative and The Sole Beneficiary of the Estate of Ng Kwun Yuen (吳坤元) Deceased v. Wu Tsun Hua and Others

Ng Yeuk Chu Winnie v. Ng Sung Kui and Another

Liu Huiyi v. Lau Chung Foon (As the Administrator of the Estate of Tsang Yuk Hing and in His Own Capacity) and Another

Lok Wai Kwan and Others v. Wong Chi Kau, The Executor of the Estate of Siu Oi Chu, Deceased

Chan Sun Judy v. Qin Xiaojian, The Sole Administrator of the Estate of Chan Wai Hing Alexander, Deceased

Wong Yat Wai, Administrator of the Estate of Wong Ching Yin, Deceased v. Lin Fei Zhu, Administratrix of the Estate of Wong Ching Yin, Deceased

Chan Hin Cheung v. Kwan Yat Hung

Chang Wing Ka John v. Chang Wing Dee

Chan Chu Wa and Another v. Chan Chau Fung, The Administratrix of the Estate of Poon Siu Chun, Deceased and Others

Tsang Tai Tai Ivy and Others v. Tsoi Kwai Ying

Bong Pik Li and Others v. Tang Yi, As the Administratrix of the Estate of Bong Won Ling, Deceased and Others