Lee Chi Keung and Others v. Wong Chi Chin and Others

Read the full judgment text of HCA 1878/2020 on BabelCite. This High Court CFI judgment was delivered on 10 November 2022.

1.  Paragraph 129 should read: "I make a costs order nisi that the plaintiffs shall bear the defendants’ costs of the Summonses.  Because of the volume of the documents involved in the 4 Actions, I take the preliminary view that such costs shall be taxed forthwith if not agreed."

Cited by 3 cases · Cites 1 case

Case No.HCA 1878/2020[2022] HKCFI 3315
Court
High Court CFI
Date10 Nov 2022
Judge
Case Document
100%Judiciary

HCA 1878/2020

[2022] HKCFI 3315

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

ACTION NO. 1878 OF 2020

--------------------------

BETWEEN    
  LEE CHI KEUNG (李志强) 1st Plaintiff
  CHAN SHING (陳成) 2nd Plaintiff
  LEE CHI KEUNG (李志强) and
CHAN SHING (陳成) (suing on behalf of
themselves as shareholders in MAX DRAGON
INTERNATIONAL INVESTMENT LIMITED)
3rd Plaintiff

and

  WONG CHI CHIN (黃熾展) 1st Defendant
  TSE SHUK FONG (謝淑芳) 2nd Defendant
  MAX DRAGON INTERNATIONAL INVESTMENT LIMITED 3rd Defendant

--------------------------

HCA 1879/2020

ACTION NO. 1879 OF 2020

--------------------------

BETWEEN    
  LEE CHI KEUNG (李志强) 1st Plaintiff
  CHAN SHING (陳成) 2nd Plaintiff
  LEE CHI KEUNG (李志强) and
CHAN SHING (陳成) (suing on behalf of
themselves as shareholders in LUCKY HONEST
INTERNATIONAL LIMITED)
3rd Plaintiff

and

  WONG CHI CHIN (黃熾展) 1st Defendant
  TSE SHUK FONG (謝淑芳) 2nd Defendant
  LUCKY HONEST INTERNATIONAL LIMITED 3rd Defendant

--------------------------

HCA 1880/2020

ACTION NO. 1880 OF 2020

--------------------------

BETWEEN    
  LEE CHI KEUNG (李志强) 1st Plaintiff
  CHAN SHING (陳成) 2nd Plaintiff
  LEE CHI KEUNG (李志强) and
CHAN SHING (陳成) (suing on behalf of
themselves as shareholders in MEGA DRAGON
INTERNATIONAL INVESTMENT LIMITED)
3rd Plaintiff

and

  WONG CHI CHIN (黃熾展) 1st Defendant
  TSE SHUK FONG (謝淑芳) 2nd Defendant
  MEGA DRAGON INTERNATIONAL INVESTMENT LIMITED 3rd Defendant

--------------------------

HCA 1881/2020

ACTION NO. 1881 OF 2020

--------------------------

BETWEEN    
  LIT HEI KING (列喜敬) 1st Plaintiff
  LIT HEI KING (列喜敬) (suing on behalf
of herself as shareholder in WISDOM
WELL INVESTMENT LIMITED)
2nd Plaintiff

and

  TSE SHUK FONG (謝淑芳) 1st Defendant
  WISDOM WELL INVESTMENT LIMITED
(志偉投資有限公司)
2nd Defendant

--------------------------

Before:  Deputy High Court Judge H. Au-Yeung in Chambers (Open to Public)

Date of Hearing:  24 August 2022

Date of Decision: 10 November 2022

Date of Corrigendum: 18 November 2022

--------------------------

CORRIGENDUM

--------------------------

Please note that the following amendment in the Decision dated 10 November 2022:

1.  Paragraph 129 should read: "I make a costs order nisi that the plaintiffs shall bear the defendants’ costs of the Summonses.  Because of the volume of the documents involved in the 4 Actions, I take the preliminary view that such costs shall be taxed forthwith if not agreed."

  (HO Tsz-kit)
  Clerk to Deputy High Court Judge
  H. Au-Yeung