Lee Tak (or Tuck) Yan and Others v. The Prudential Enterprise Ltd and Others

Read the full judgment text of HCCW 594/1999 on BabelCite. This High Court CFI judgment was delivered on 19 August 2003.

1. On the 2nd line of paragraph 20(1), the action number of "HCCW592/1999" should read "HCCW59 4 /1999".

Case No.HCCW 594/1999
Court
High Court CFI
Date19 Aug 2003
Judge
Case Document
100%Judiciary

HCA004225BM/2001

HCCW594/1999

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

COMPANIES WINDING-UP PROCEEDINGS NO.594 OF 1999

----------------------

IN THE MATTER of THE PRUDENTIAL ENTERPRISES, LIMITED

AND

IN THE MATTER of the COMPANIES ORDINANCE, Cap.32 of the Laws of Hong Kong

-----------------------

HCA1240/2001

ACTION NO.1240 OF 2001

------------------------

BETWEEN
LEE TAK (or TUCK) YAN 1st Plaintiff
LEE KIM also known as LEE WING KIM MAY 2nd Plaintiff
LEE JICK also known as LEE WING TSIT
also known as HELEN HUANG
3rd Plaintiff
LEE CHI also known as LEE WING CHEE
also known as CHRISTINE KUAN
4th Plaintiff
LEE TAK YAN and LEE WING KIM MAY, Executors
of the Estate of LEE MAN WAH alias LEE WAI LOY
alias LEE CHEONG YEE
5th Plaintiff
LEE TAK YAN and LEE WING KIM MAY, appointed
Executors of the Estate of NG CHAN WAH (or WA)
6th Plaintiff
LEE HON FAI, LEE HON YUEN and LEE HON YIN,
the appointed Executors of the Estate of
LEE CHAI CHEONG (or CHONG)
7th Plaintiff
LEE CHAI KWONG 8th Plaintiff
LEE CHAI HONG 9th Plaintiff
LEE WAI YING 10th Plaintiff
LEE TSE (or CHEE) NGOR, MORETA 11th Plaintiff
LEE HON YUEN 12th Plaintiff
LEE HON YIN 13th Plaintiff
LEE WAI MING 14th Plaintiff
HY & HT LEE BROTHERS
& LIMITEDCOMPANY
15th Plaintiff
AND
THE PRUDENTIAL ENTERPRISE LIMITED 1st Defendant
SAMUEL TAK LEE also known as
LEE TAK (or TUCK) YEE
2nd Defendant
LEE KIN LOND PATRICK 3rd Defendant
LI KIN KAN SAMATHUR 4th Defendant
LEE KIN PAN CHRISTOPHER 5th Defendant
LEE KIN YEE ANNABELL 6th Defendant
N & L INVESTMENT LIMITED 7th Defendant
INTERSTITIAL HOLDINGS LIMITED 8th Defendant
MOUNT EDEN LAND LIMITED 9th Defendant
MOUNT COOK LAND LIMITED 10th Defendant

------------------------

HCA4225/2001

ACTION NO.4225 OF 2001

---------------------

BETWEEN
LEE TAK (or TUCK) YAN 1st Plaintiff
LEE KIM also known as LEE WING KIM MAY 2nd Plaintiff
LEE JICK also known as LEE WING TSIT
also known as HELEN HUANG
3rd Plaintiff
LEE CHI also known as LEE WING CHEE
also known as CHRISTINE KUAN
4th Plaintiff
LEE TAK YAN and LEE WING KIM MAY, Executors
of the Estate of LEE MAN WAH alias LEE WAI LOY
alias LEE CHEONG YEE
5th Plaintiff
LEE TAK YAN and LEE WING KIM MAY, appointed
Executors of the Estate of NG CHAN WAH (or WA)
6th Plaintiff
LEE HON FAI, LEE HON YUEN and LEE HON YIN,
the appointed Executors of the Estate of
LEE CHAI CHEONG (or CHONG)
7th Plaintiff
LEE CHAI KWONG 8th Plaintiff
LEE CHAI HONG 9th Plaintiff
LEE WAI YING 10th Plaintiff
LEE TSE (or CHEE) NGOR, MORETA 11th Plaintiff
LEE HON YUEN 12th Plaintiff
LEE HON YIN 13th Plaintiff
LEE WAI MING 14th Plaintiff
HY & HT LEE BROTHERS
& COMPANY LIMITED
15th Plaintiff
AND
THE PRUDENTIAL ENTERPRISES, LIMITED 1st Defendant
SAMUEL TAK LEE also known as
LEE TAK (or TUCK) YEE
2nd Defendant
LEE KIN LOND PATRICK 3rd Defendant
LI KIN KAN SAMATHUR 4th Defendant
N&L INVESTMENT LIMITED 5th Defendant
ANDREW MA & COMPANY (a firm) 6th Defendant
AND
MW LEE & SON ENTERPRISES LIMITED 1st Third Party
GREENHILL ENTERPRISES LIMITED 2nd Third Party
SH LEUNG & CO. (a firm) 3rd Third Party

---------------------

Coram : Hon Chu J in Chambers

Date of Hearing : 8 August 2003

Date of Decision : 19 August 2003

--------------------------------

C O R R I G E N D A

--------------------------------

1. On the 2nd line of paragraph 20(1), the action number of "HCCW592/1999" should read "HCCW594/1999".

2. On the 1st line of paragraph 23(2), insert after "if so advised", the words "on or before 28 September 2003".

3. On the 3rd line of paragraph 23(2), the date " 31 July 200" should read "31 July 2003".

4. On the 2nd line of paragraph 23(3), insert at the end of the paragraph the words "by 1 September 2003".

5. On the 2nd line of paragraph 26(5), insert after "if so advised", the words "on or before 7 November 2003".

Rebecca Lai (Ms)
Clerk to the Honourable Madam Justice Chu
27 August 2003