BabelCite

Ma Po Chim, Percy and Others v. Lee Tung Hai, Leo and Others

Read the full judgment text of CACV 160/2007 on BabelCite. This Court of Appeal judgment was delivered on 27 February 2008.

1. The second last sentence in paragraph 45 should read “We make an order nisi that the costs of appeals be paid by the 3rd Respondent ”.

Cited by 4 cases

Case No.CACV 160/2007
Court
Court of Appeal
Date27 Feb 2008
Judge—
Case Document
100%Judiciary

CACV 160/2007 & CACV 161/2007

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF APPEAL

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 160 AND 161 OF 2007

(ON APPEAL FROM HCMP NO. 3253 OF 2004)

______________________

  IN THE MATTER of CHUNGSHAN COMMERCIAL ASSOCIATION, HONG KONG (A company limited by guarantee and not having any share capital with word “Limited” being omitted by licence granted by the Registrar of Companies under delegated powers on 25th August, 1967)(香港中山僑商會) 
  and
  IN THE MATTER of Section 168A of the Companies Ordinance, Cap. 32

BETWEEN

  MA PO CHIM, PERCY(馬寶潛) Petitioners
  GOCK PING, JAMES(郭平)  
  LAM NIN(林年)  
  LI TIN KUEN(李天權)  
  WONG WING NIN(黃永年)  
  MA CHIU WAN(馬超寰)  
  WONG FUNG MING(黃鳳鳴)  
  WONG LAU(黃流)  
  WONG YUI KWONG(黃銳光)  
  LO HING(盧慶)  
  and  
  LEE TUNG HAI, LEO(李東海) 1st Respondent
  PANG SIU WING alias PANG WING
(彭少榮又名彭榮) 		2nd Respondent
  CHUNGSHAN COMMERCIAL ASSOCIATION, HONG KONG 3rd Respondent
  (a Company Limited by guarantee and not having any share Capital with word “Limited” being omitted by licence granted by the Registrar of Companies under delegated powers on 25th August, 1967)
(香港中山僑商會) 		 
  MO LOONG KWONG 4th Respondent
  LEE DAI CHUNG 5th Respondent
  YUEN CHO MO 6th Respondent

______________________

Before : Hon , Stock JA and A Cheung J in Court

Date of Hearing : 19 February 2008

Date of Judgment : 27 February 2008

Date of Corrigendum : 28 February 2008

______________________

CORRIGENDUM

______________________

1.The second last sentence in paragraph 45 should read “We make an order nisi that the costs of appeals be paid by the 3rd Respondent”.

  (Pamela Au) (Miss)
Clerk to Hon Tang VP

Cited by 4 cases

Other judgments that cite this case

Ma Po Chim, Percy and Others v. Lee Tung Hai, Leo and Others
Court of Appeal10 Jul 2007
Ma Po Chim, Percy and Others v. Lee Tung Hai, Leo and Others
High Court CFI13 Jun 2007
Ma Po Chim, Percy and Others v. Lee Tung Hai, Leo and Others
Court of Appeal
Full analysis
27 Feb 2008
伍威 訴 劉一萍
Court of Appeal
Full analysis
27 Mar 2009
Other Judgments in This Case

Further hearings and rulings under CACV 160/2007

Ma Po Chim, Percy and Others v. Lee Tung Hai, Leo and Others
Court of Appeal10 Jul 2007
Ma Po Chim, Percy and Others v. Lee Tung Hai, Leo and Others
Court of Appeal10 Jul 2007
Ma Po Chim, Percy and Others v. Lee Tung Hai, Leo and Others
Court of Appeal
Full analysis
27 Feb 2008
Ma Po Chim, Percy and Others v. Lee Tung Hai, Leo and Others
Court of Appeal27 Feb 2008
Ma Po Chim, Percy and Others v. Lee Tung Hai, Leo and Others
Court of Appeal27 Feb 2008