Power Securities Co Ltd (Formerly Known As Jun Yang Securities Co Ltd) v. Sin Kwok Lam and Others

Case No.CACV 594/2019[2023] HKCA 594

Court

Court of Appeal

Date21 Apr 2023

JudgeChu VP, Yuen JA, Barma JA

Case Document

100%

CACV 594/2019 & CACV 59/2020

(Heard Together)

[2023] HKCA 594

On Appeal From [2019] HKCFI 2920

CACV 594/2019

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF APPEAL

CIVIL APPEAL NO 594 OF 2019

(ON APPEAL FROM HCA NO 1719 OF 2018 AND

HCA NO 1071 OF 2019)

_________________________________________

HCA 1719/2018

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

ACTION NO 1719 OF 2018

___________________________________________

BETWEEN
	POWER SECURITIES COMPANY LIMITED (權威證券有限公司) (formerly known as JUN YANG SECURITIES COMPANY LIMITED (君陽證券有限公司))	Plaintiff
	and
	SIN KWOK LAM	1^st Defendant
	MAI SHAO HANG	2^nd Defendant
	BEST YEAR ENTERPRISES LIMITED (好年企業有限公司) (in liquidation)	3^rd Defendant
	ENHANCE PACIFIC LIMITED	4^th Defendant

______________________________________

(By Original Action)

BETWEEN
	BEST YEAR ENTERPRISES LIMITED (好年企業有限公司) (in liquidation)	1^st Plaintiff
	SIN KWOK LAM	2^nd Plaintiff
	and
	POWER SECURITIES COMPANY LIMITED (權威證券有限公司) (formerly known as JUN YANG SECURITIES COMPANY LIMITED (君陽證券有限公司))	1^st Defendant
	NG KAM LUNG VOLAIS	2^nd Defendant
	TANG CHING HO	3^rd Defendant
	SIT SAI HUNG, BILLY	4^th Defendant

______________________________________

(By Counterclaim)

AND

HCA 1071/2019

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

ACTION NO 1071 OF 2019

________________________

BETWEEN
	BEST YEAR ENTERPRISES LIMITED (好年企業有限公司) (in liquidation)	1^st Plaintiff
	SIN KWOK LAM	2^nd Plaintiff
	and
	POWER SECURITIES COMPANY LIMITED (權威證券有限公司) (formerly known as JUN YANG SECURITIES COMPANY LIMITED (君陽證券有限公司))	1^st Defendant
	TANG CHING HO	2^nd Defendant

________________________

(HEARD TOGETHER)

AND

CACV 59/2020

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF APPEAL

CIVIL APPEAL NO 59 OF 2020

(ON APPEAL FROM HCA NO 1071 OF 2019)

________________________

BETWEEN
	BEST YEAR ENTERPRISES LIMITED (好年企業有限公司) (in liquidation)	1^st Plaintiff
	SIN KWOK LAM	2^nd Plaintiff
	and
	POWER SECURITIES COMPANY LIMITED (權威證券有限公司) (formerly known as JUN YANG SECURITIES COMPANY LIMITED (君陽證券有限公司))	1^st Defendant
	TANG CHING HO	2^nd Defendant

______________________

(HEARD TOGETHER)

Before:

Hon Chu VP, Yuen and Barma JJA in Court

Date of Hearing:	9 July 2021
Dates of Post-hearing Submissions:	24 August 2021, 26 August 2021 and 31 August 2021

Date of Judgment:

21 April 2023

________________________

CORRIGENDUM

________________________

Please note the following corrigendum for the Judgment dated 21 April 2023: -

1.At page 1 between line C and line D,

“On Appeal From [2021] HKCFI 2920” should read

“On Appeal From [2019] HKCFI 2920”

Dated this 21^st day of June, 2023

(Lisa LEUNG)
for Registrar, High Court

Cites 5 cases

Cases cited in this judgment

Power Securities Co Ltd (Formerly Known As Jun Yang Securities Co Ltd) v. Sin Kwok Lam and Others

[2023] HKCA 594 · Court of Appeal

Power Securities Co Ltd (Formerly Known As Jun Yang Securities Co Ltd) v. Sin Kwok Lam and Others

[2019] HKCFI 2920 · High Court CFI

Re Pham Huy Toi

[2021] HKCFI 2920 · High Court CFI

Power Securities Co Ltd (Formerly Known As Jun Yang Securities Co Ltd) v. Sin Kwok Lam and Others

CACV 594/2019 · Court of Appeal

Related Cases

Ranked by citation overlap · cases that cite each other appear first

Power Securities Co Ltd (Formerly Known As Jun Yang Securities Co Ltd) v. Sin Kwok Lam and Others

CACV 594/2019 · Court of Appeal

4 shared citations

Zhang Rui Kang and Others v. Tunghsu Group Co Ltd and Others

HCA 1359/2021 · High Court CFI

2 shared citations

Zl v. Wy and Others

HCMP 948/2020 · High Court CFI

China Shanshui Cement Group Ltd and Others v. Tianrui (International) Holding Company Ltd and Others

HCA 548/2019 · High Court CFI

Cited by 11 cases

Other judgments that cite this case

China Shanshui Cement Group Ltd and Others v. Tianrui (International) Holding Company Ltd and Others

Peking University Resources (Holdings) Company Ltd v. Peking University Resources Group Co., Ltd and Others

鍾文彬對陳秀貞及另二人

Lei Chi Kang v. Iconic Asia Company Ltd and Another

Other Judgments in This Case

Further hearings and rulings under CACV 594/2019

Power Securities Co Ltd (Formerly Known As Jun Yang Securities Co Ltd) v. Sin Kwok Lam and Others

Court of Appeal

Best Year Enterprises Ltd (in Liquidation) and Another v. Power Securities Co Ltd (Formerly Known As Jun Yang Securities Co Ltd) and Another

Court of Appeal

Best Year Enterprises Ltd (in Liquidation) and Another v. Power Securities Co Ltd (Formerly Known As Jun Yang Securities Co Ltd) and Another

Court of Appeal