Case Document

100%Judiciary

HCPI 235/2011, HCPI 671/2007
& HCPI 228/2010

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

PERSONAL INJURIES ACTION NO. 235 OF 2011

-------------------------

BETWEEN
	CHAN PAK TING	Plaintiff
and
	CHAN CHI KUEN	1st Defendant
	CHAN YIU FAI JOE	2nd Defendant

-------------------------

AND

PERSONAL INJURIES ACTION NO. 671 OF 2007

-------------------------

BETWEEN
	LI KA WAI (A Minor) by his mother and next friend SO YUET WA	Plaintiff
	and
	HOSPITAL AUTHORITY	Defendant

-------------------------

AND

PERSONAL INJURIES ACTION NO. 228 OF 2010

-------------------------

BETWEEN
	YUEN HIU TUNG (A Minor) by her grandmother And Next Friend YIP HEI SIU	Plaintiff
	and
	HOSPITAL AUTHORITY	Defendant
-------------------------
	(HEARD TOGETHER)

Before : Hon Bharwaney J in Court

Dates of Hearing : 8-11 January 2013

Date of Judgment : 7 February 2013

---------------------

CORRIGENDA

---------------------

Insert the following sentence after the sentence, “I find that the management fee for this exercise ought not to exceed 0.75% of the values of the EFNs and bonds to be acquired.”, appearing on p.83F of the Judgment:

“This conclusion is supported by comparing the 5-year and 7-year rates of return for MPF Hong Kong Dollar Bond, in Table 5.1 (before deducting management fee) and Table 5.1 (after deducting management fee), which shows that the fee charged for this MPF scheme fund was 1.1% which covered not only the cost of management but also custodian charges, and record keeping and administration charges.”