Case Document

100%Judiciary

HCPI 235/2011, HCPI 671/2007
& HCPI 228/2010

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

PERSONAL INJURIES ACTION NO. 235 OF 2011

-------------------------

BETWEEN
	CHAN PAK TING	Plaintiff
and
	CHAN CHI KUEN	1st Defendant
	CHAN YIU FAI JOE	2nd Defendant
-------------------------

AND

PERSONAL INJURIES ACTION NO. 671 OF 2007

-------------------------

BETWEEN
	LI KA WAI (A Minor) by his mother and next friend SO YUET WA	Plaintiff
	and
	HOSPITAL AUTHORITY	Defendant
-------------------------

AND

PERSONAL INJURIES ACTION NO. 228 OF 2010

-------------------------

BETWEEN
	YUEN HIU TUNG (A Minor) by her grandmother And Next Friend YIP HEI SIU	Plaintiff
	and
	HOSPITAL AUTHORITY	Defendant
-------------------------

(HEARD TOGETHER)

Before : Hon Bharwaney J in Court

Dates of Hearing : 8-11 January 2013

Date of Judgment : 7 February 2013

------------------------

CORRIGENDUM

------------------------

Please note the following amendments in the Judgment handed down on 7 February 2013:

(1) Page 4, line J-Q: “her” instead of “his”, “She” instead of “He” and “she” instead of “he”.

(2) Page 20, line E-F: “prophet” instead of “profit”.

(3) Page 20, line S: “2001 to 2012”instead of “2011 to 2012”

(4) Page 25, line K-L: “would there be double recovery” instead of “would there double recovery”

(5) Page 26, line J: “in the last row” instead of “in the row”.

(6) Page 44, line L-M: “60% in bonds” instead of “80% in bonds”.

(7) Page 50, line F: “will affect” instead of “willaffect”

(8) Page 50, line O: “Sir Michael Ogden QC” instead of “Lord Ogden QC”.

(9) Page 52 line S-T: “Mr Badenoch QC” instead of “Mr Badenock QC”.

(10) Page 56, line 1-J: “had not been available” instead of “had not available”.

(11) Page 59, line F: “Ms Sin” instead of “Mr Sin”.

(12) Page 89, line S: “Ms Leung Mei Wah” be included after “Mr Samuel Chan”.